5 ms·
I'd just like to see more evidence and information before making judgment here. There's no response from Zoom whatsoever, which is odd. Could this have been ot
by crazygringo 6y ago
I'd just like to see more evidence and information before making judgment here.
There's no response from Zoom whatsoever, which is odd. Could this have been other users maliciously reporting the account as abuse, and it was closed automatically? Or something else similar?
Or if China is putting pressure on Zoom, then how exactly?
If Zoom, an American company, really did intentionally close the account of someone living in the US, because the Chinese government asked them to for political reasons, that does sound outrageous.
But it's so outrageous that I actually have a hard time believing it's true. It feels like business suicide. I want to hear Zoom's side here first -- which I expect we will soon, since this story broke only 2 hours ago.
- bagacrap 6y agoHow is that outrageous? US companies cow tow to CCP all the time, e.g. the NBA. If you're trying not to get blacklisted by the world's second largest market then it makes plenty of sense.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- pyrophane 6y agoI don't think this compares directly to the now-commonplace kowtowing that you are referring to. That would be more akin to Zoom, for example, retracting and apologizing for some public statement that it made in recognition of the Tiananmen Square protests. Instead, this is a US-based communications platform, barring its US-based users from discussing something that is offensive to a foreign regime, and doing so outside of any official rules that they have made public. Now, of course, you are correct, this has nothing to do with any kind of deeply held values. It is merely about money. I don't think that makes it better.
- kryptiskt 6y agoBut that's why we constantly have to remind these companies that such sycophancy will cost them dearly in the world's largest market.
- orsenthil 6y agoHere are more details shared by Humanitarian China with links to the video recordings and the photos of Zoom blockage. https://docs.google.com/document/d/12DM3ccTe70yzqCDPu9uXlCD7.. https://docs.google.com/document/d/12DM3ccTe70yzqCDPu9uXlCD7....
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- crazygringo 6y agoThat link (the one in your other comment works) doesn't really say anything the article doesn't already. All it says is that the account was shut down a week after the event, and that "it seems possible ZOOM acted on pressure from the CCP to shut down our account". That appears to be pure conjecture however, which is why I want to hear Zoom's side. Nobody's disputing the account was blocked, but there's zero information on why.
- orsenthil 6y agoIt gives proof which I was looking for.
- wonnage 6y agoIt looks like the account was reinstated: https://twitter.com/ZhouFengSuo/status/1270828746589769732?s=20 https://twitter.com/ZhouFengSuo/status/1270828746589769732?s... My guess is that they were under pressure to close all the accounts in the meeting, backpedaled after the article, and reenabled the non-Chinese ones. Honestly, if they just did this to begin with, it'd be understandable? They just fucked up and blocked the non-China accounts too, triggering the China Watchers of which this reporter is a prime member of. I ultimately see companies adopting the TikTok model, where Chinese users basically get their own sandboxed app and company structure subject to Chinese law that nobody else can communicate with.
- loceng 6y agoAnd arguably as a society standing up for democracy and free speech should begin to not use any such platforms who sandbox to support these bad actor governments.
- gruez 6y ago>If Zoom, an American company, really did intentionally close the account of someone living in the US, because the Chinese government asked them to for political reasons, that does sound outrageous. Most of their devs are from china. https://www.cnbc.com/2019/03/26/zoom-key-profit-driver-ahead-of-ipo-engineers-in-china.html https://www.cnbc.com/2019/03/26/zoom-key-profit-driver-ahead... >Zoom disclosed in its IPO prospectus last week that most of its product development personnel are based in China Presumably they don't want to lose their pool of cheap programmers.
- gowld 6y agoZoom is a multinational company.
- learc83 6y agoZoom may operate in multiple countries. But they are physically and legally headquartered in the United States.