2 ms·
> China could technically spin off their censorship functions to a privately owned company that would wholly depend on the state-issued license to operate and w
by jedberg 6y ago
> China could technically spin off their censorship functions to a privately owned company that would wholly depend on the state-issued license to operate and would keep doing exactly the same thing.
If the private company requires a state-issued license, and that license is dependent on the content on the site, then it's still government censorship.
In America, you can still start a competing private company and allow any opinion you want. In China you can't do that.
- john_moscow 6y agoIn theory, yes. In practice, since Google and Facebook are free to end users, outcompeting them would require raising enormous amounts of capital. So you would depend on the approval of a rather small (and mind you, non-elected) group of individuals. I really don't think it's about the wording you put on the decision maker's badge. It's about who's interests they represent and the structure of their incentives. Government-drivern censorship is bad, because their incentive would become to stay in power no matter what. Monopolies act the same way.