4 ms·
Ask YC: Why not charge for downvotes?
Please don't downvote comments that are only mildly mistaken or disagreeable to scores as low as -10. That kind of score should only be for spams and trolls.
Why not charge for downvotes? Make downvoting cost a tiny sliver of karma. Or perhaps make it a statistical model: with every downvote, there is a small chance you will lose 1 karma point.
People who strongly disagree with something will still downvote, but if something you hate is already -5, why pile on? You'll save your downvotes for things closer to zero.
- Mystalic 18y agoThen there's no incentive to downvote at all. I know I'll stop downvoting (and I rarely do it) to protect my Karma. You're not trying to decrease downvoting, you're trying to have downvoting occur for the right reasons. Dismal idea. At least you tried, though.
- cconstantine 18y agoReally? With 200+ karma you wouldn't be willing to knock someone down every once in awhile... ya know, take one for the team? I'm below 50 karma atm. and I think it might be worth it once in awhile. I'd rather have this place be a good community than gobble up karma. All it takes is for a small percentage of suckers like me to knock down the truly awful posts into obscurity. I'm not even sure if I like people knowing exactly what causes karma to move. Allowing people to know the rules of the game invites people to 'game' the system for more points. Is the point of the site to get lots of karma, or to build a worthwhile community? At any rate. I wouldn't say it's a dismal idea.
- raganwald 18y agoReally? With 200+ karma you wouldn't be willing to knock someone down every once in awhile... ya know, take one for the team? If certain things cost karma, karma becomes currency. You earn it in order to spend it on stuff you want to do. Like downvoting.
- Mystalic 18y agoI personally don't want to see Karma become currency. I'm part of a message board that does something like that, and its quality of posters has dropped over the years.
- cconstantine 18y agoYeah, there's something about karma that makes people go crazy. Maybe it has something to do with people wanting validation. I don't get it. I know pg uses this place as a kind of 'extended interview' for YC, and I"m guessing he uses karma when evaluating someone. If karma really does corrupt perhaps it'd be best to hide it from users? I don't really have an answer. I'm simply not convinced this idea of costing karma to down vote someone is a bad idea.
- raganwald 18y agoDismal idea. At least you tried, though. Therein you have the explanation for all of my failures and all of my successes. A large number of dismal ideas combined with a willingness to try again :-)
- syntaxfree 18y agoVotes should be traded in between users for money. Micropayments aren't really necessary if you're in for the mid-run, as Adsense et al. prove.
- gexla 18y agoI agree that downvoting sucks though I don't think losing Karma is the answer. Maybe there should just be a cap. People really do love to pile on here. I have long valuable posts that might get a couple of up votes but a couple of bad posts that have cut my karma in half. This really makes me feel like I just shouldn't comment at all. If I do comment, then it pressures me to post a lame "me too" or "I agree" post rather than risking an idea that people may not agree with. Just because the majority does not like your idea does not make your idea wrong, a community heavy in startups should know this better than any.
- babul 18y agoWhat is the obsession with karma? Should we not up-vote the things we like and down-vote those we don't without having to worry about karma? Is it not supposed to be a measure of the value we find in things rather than with these political connotations?