3 ms·
This is true, but better tooled, equipped humans do more work and so you need fewer of them. When your landscaping company buys an excavator, one person can no
by taneq 6y ago
This is true, but better tooled, equipped humans do more work and so you need fewer of them.
When your landscaping company buys an excavator, one person can now move as much earth as 15 people used to. You don't keep the other 14 on the payroll.
- 6510 6y agoWhat I've seen is that the competitor buys the excavator and the 15 people have to do the work for similar pay. The salaries go down, amount of work per worker goes up and the competitor makes exotic profits. I've seen one fascinating example where pay per unit eventually boiled down to 40 cents per hour. That was the point where the automatons simply could no longer keep up. Some would decline to do the manual work. Those who did got the less frequent better paid contracts that paid up to 20 euro per hour. (for which no machine exists)
- aga98mtl 6y agoA larger amount of people can now afford landscaping services because earth moving cost have now gone down. Poor people used to go barefoot before industrialization. Producing more with less human input is how we raise the living standards of everyone in the long term.
- taneq 6y agoThe Jevons paradox absolutely does play a part, especially at first, but I don't believe it's enough for higher efficiency to result in an overall win (edit: for the employees). Most markets saturate surprisingly quickly when you apply 10x - 100x efficiency increases.
- dugditches 6y agoYou see this in factories as well. Not pure 'automation' but rather 1 person overseeing several lightly automated processes. So while 25 years ago you had 4 Operators doing 4 tasks together, you now have 1 Operator doing the 4 tasks with automated assistance. Also often this person will make less than his individual 4 predecessors due to 'Tiered' wage systems. While being more physically(previous operators taking turns doing physical tasks, etc) and now mentally exhausted(ensuring process is correct) than them as well.