6 ms·
Free will is inescapable. Without it, you have no ability to assign moral blame, which means law and order become impossible. If someone punches you in the face
by naasking 6y ago
Free will is inescapable. Without it, you have no ability to assign moral blame, which means law and order become impossible. If someone punches you in the face unprovoked, you are just as responsible for putting your face where his fist was going to be. Thus, there's no justification for your attacker to be rehabilitated rather than you, an innocent victim.
Your issue is not with free will, but with retributive justice, ie. the argument that moral blame deserves punishment.
- jbay808 6y ago> Thus, there's no justification for your attacker to be rehabilitated rather than you, an innocent victim Free will or not, it's pretty easy to see which party we should confine to reduce the frequency of future face injuries.
- CMCDragonkai 6y agoWhy "should" we do anything in the absence of free will. What will happen is what will happen. Everything is inevitable, including the punch to the face.
- jbay808 6y agoWhy do you feel like a novel has suspense, when the ending is sitting right there in front of you, already written, in the pages that you haven't read yet? Determinism or not, you have to wait to find out what tomorrow will bring. And tomorrow still depends on what you do today -- even if what you do today is fully determined by yesterday. If losing the illusion of free will means you'll sit there on your sofa letting time pass, because why make any effort if the future is already written, then you're just misunderstanding determinism. I believe the future is already written, but I'm still going to work as hard as I can to make sure that it turns out to be as good a future as possible. Once you've internalized a deterministic worldview, this is not a contradiction. (If you're familiar with Newcomb's problem, I'd choose one box). https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Newcomb%27s_paradox https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Newcomb%27s_paradox
- CMCDragonkai 6y agoAny book has suspense for myself because it might have utility and lessons that enrich my understanding of life. Not simply because it is not-yet-known to myself. This analogy doesn't make sense to me. Whether you think it is an illusion or not is irrelevant. A deterministic world means you were determined to believe it is an illusion. Just as others may be determined to believe that it isn't an illusion. Thus it is impossible for me to sit on a couch and do nothing, because I would be determined to believe in free will and not sit on a couch and do nothing. On a personal note, I often feel that things that don't have free will don't deserve moral blame, but this also means they don't deserve anything at all. No punishment, no reward. One can judge such things in the same way one might judge a rock.
- GoblinSlayer 6y agoCausality there goes in the opposite direction. Fatalism is inspired by existential crisis, not by practical considerations. And trading practicality for existential crisis is unwise: you only lose everything and don't obtain anything.
- __m 6y agoImposing the false concept of free will just to be able to morally put someone in jail seems immoral. Imposing laws that most of society agrees with is a pragmatic necessity.
- naasking 6y ago> Imposing the false concept of free will just to be able to morally put someone in jail seems immoral Who said that? In fact, I said that this exact argument is a mistake, conflating free will with retributive justice.
- abellerose 6y agoNo. Nobody being responsible doesn't negate rehabilitation for the person that is deranged. The goal of humanity is debatable but generally having everyone functioning in a way that doesn't harm others and including themselves is preferred. So I don't see how it's logical to place the blame on the victim and unless you're just trying to be silly with not really understanding determinism is just from the basis of logic like the foregoing.
- naasking 6y ago> Nobody being responsible doesn't negate rehabilitation for the person that is deranged. There is no way to justify who is deranged without moral blame. There is no victim and no perpetrator. A person who attacked you without provocation is just responding to the environment established by society. Your expectation that you should not be punched in the face is the same. Why is your expectation to not be punched justified over his desire to punch you?
- abellerose 6y agoThe approach you’re proposing is illogical that’s why. Although everything is destined, that doesn’t negate the majority desire to treat a person who becomes ill and potentially very sick. Similar as someone that becomes mentally deranged by his/her order of events resulting in being mentally ill. I used to have a colleague that shared your rhetoric and he very much made a big leap in his assumption that people adopting determinism will all of a sudden become metaphorically motionless by thinking the majority will not try to fix people that become ill.
- naasking 6y ago> Although everything is destined, that doesn’t negate the majority desire to treat a person who becomes ill and potentially very sick. So majority desires are all that matters? So you agree with mob rule and think the tyranny of the majority is perfectly ok? > I used to have a colleague that shared your rhetoric and he very much made a big leap in his assumption that people adopting determinism will all of a sudden become metaphorically motionless by thinking the majority will not try to fix people that become ill. I have no problem with determinism as I'm a Compatibilist. I think you've made a few assumptions about what I believe that aren't justified, so if you're actually interested in understanding what I'm saying, you can read my elaboration on free will here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23476919 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23476919
- dghf 6y ago> Free will is inescapable. Without it, you have no ability to assign moral blame, which means law and order become impossible. Even if that were the case, that doesn't bear on whether or not free will exists. Having reasons to want something to be true doesn't in itself make it true.
- naasking 6y agoYou're missing the last step that closes the loop: in order for society to exist and function, moral blame is essential. Therefore some notion of moral responsibility for breaking the law must be imposed, so we invent some quasi-free will notion that's compatible with determinism in order to do this. But how do you know this quasi-free will notion isn't exactly what people really mean by free will. In fact, that appears to be the case: https://www.researchgate.net/publication/274892120_Why_Compatibilist_Intuitions_are_not_Mistaken_A_Reply_to_Feltz_and_Millan https://www.researchgate.net/publication/274892120_Why_Compa...
- dghf 6y ago>You're missing the last step that closes the loop: in order for society to exist and function, moral blame is essential. Therefore some notion of moral responsibility for breaking the law must be imposed, so we invent some quasi-free will notion that's compatible with determinism in order to do this. If your argument that it is necessary for the public to believe in free will (because of the negative consequences if they don't), regardless of whether or not it actually exists, then that's different. I thought you were arguing that free will must necessarily exist because of those consequences. I apologise and withdraw.
- naasking 6y ago> I thought you were arguing that free will must necessarily exist because of those consequences. I'm saying that this is exactly what most people really mean by free will [1], and that people like you who claim that free will doesn't exist are making a mistake in assuming free will is something that it isn't. Typically, you're arguing against a theistic conception of free will with "souls" and whatnot, but that's just one (incoherent) conception of free will and not the whole debate. "Free will" is ultimately some notion of control over one's actions that grounds moral responsibility: https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/freewill/ https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/freewill/ If you acknowledge that being able to designate who is responsible for some undesirable outcome is a necessary condition for being able to remedy it, then you are acknowledging some notion of moral blame. If you further accept that people's actions can be described counterfactually by their thoughts, feelings and beliefs, then that implies some sort of control over those actions. Therefore we have control + moral responsibility, and that's free will (in Compatibilism). If this seems kind of familiar, it should! Compatibilism was first formulated from our notions of free will from law. Notice how if you remove the control requirement (say they had a tumour driving some behaviour, or they're insane), a person is no longer acting of their own free will and so are not responsible for their actions. This is what I meant by free will being inevitable. No society can exist without blame for breaking the law. You might define the terms to avoid terms like "blame" and "free will", as hard determinists try to do, but the ultimate function will be the exact same. [1] https://www.researchgate.net/publication/274892120_Why_Compatibilist_Intuitions_are_not_Mistaken_A_Reply_to_Feltz_and_Millan https://www.researchgate.net/publication/274892120_Why_Compa...
- JoeAltmaier 6y agoIts all semantics. If there's no free will, then we have no choice over assigning moral blame either. It is what it is. Arguments also become irrelevant, since we're destined to play out the drama exactly as we have. Like some static 4D statuary in a forgotten temple. There's no point in trying to convince anyone, as they have 'already' been sculpted as they are. So argument can't be said to have any real effect, as its just more posed stone.