3 ms·
This sort of paranoic fearmongering is exactly the sort of propaganda that pushes society towards that authoritarian corporate dystopia in which trust is forced
by userbinator 6y ago
This sort of paranoic fearmongering is exactly the sort of propaganda that pushes society towards that authoritarian corporate dystopia in which trust is forced by those in power, and which you have no control over. We are slowly losing our freedom to choose even whom to trust, thanks to this idea that these "multinational corporations" are somehow deities.
You highly underestimate the skill of the community, and how it only takes one person to find out and spread the news if something is amiss. Source isn't needed, and doesn't tell the whole story anyway. (See: Ken Thompson Hack.)
the multinational corporation that could lose hundreds of billions of dollars if they inappropriately abuse my privacy
The corporation which has lawyers and knows exactly how to spin their spyware to carefully evade such laws?
Windows 10 would clearly be considered spyware 10 or even 5 years ago. Yet somehow Microsoft has convinced the general public that it isn't, and we are supposed to still trust them?
Edit: downloaded it to take a look. Appears to be written in easily-reversible .NET and not even obfuscated, so go ahead and analyse it yourself if you don't trust it. (If it was obfuscated, that would make my suspicion jump.)
Edit2: looks like people still think I'm wrong - go look at the binary yourself instead of blindly downvoting just because you don't want to do the thinking yourself. The more power you let them have, the more they will abuse it.
- catalogia 6y agoIt's not fearmongering to question the low standard Windows developers and their users seem to consider routine. That Windows users have chosen to accept Windows becoming spyware is just another manifestation of that same problem, not a refutation of it!
- vezycash 6y agoKnowledge comes before acceptance. Apart from those of us who live on tech sites, normal users would be completely clueless. Even among those who know, only a fraction would be bothered enough to take action.
- catalogia 6y agoMany Windows users may not know there's a better way, but I can hardly think that's an excuse for developers writing proprietary freeware for Windows. Surely they've heard of open source at some point, they just don't give a damn.
- harrygeez 6y agoI don't know any companies in this day that doesn't collect users' usage and analytics. Very few do better by making it opt-in
- userbinator 6y agoIt absolutely is fearmongering when you default to assuming maliciousness/bad faith just because the author is relatively unknown. There's nothing deep/unusual about what this program does, and I assure you that if it was created with malicious intent, it would not remain undiscovered for very long. That Windows users have chosen to accept Windows becoming spyware The developers of this, and others, are clearly fighting against it.
- catalogia 6y agoThe developers of this program are asking windows users to install proprietary freeware from anonymous developers. This exemplifies Windows software culture, the very same culture that made Windows users compliant enough to tolerate Windows 10 in the first place. The developers of this software, in choosing to make it proprietary freeware, are reinforcing this culture.
- tonyedgecombe 6y agothe low standard Windows developers and their users seem to consider routine Compared to just about every SaaS product?
- t0mmyb0y 6y ago"Windows 10 would clearly be considered spyware 10 or even 5 years ago. Yet somehow Microsoft has convinced the general public that it isn't, and we are supposed to still trust them?" No. Microsoft decided to go into the data business with Win10. They very publicly partnered with the federal government to feed them info from any Win10 system that 'might' have something illegal on it. Go back and find their statements prior to release, they are downright dystopian. So yes, Microsoft has publicly said if they detect a music track that may have been downloaded 'illegally', they will 'package it and all your info and send it to the feds'. It isn't spyware if you partner with the spies.
- Hawxy 6y ago> So yes, Microsoft has publicly said if they detect a music track that may have been downloaded 'illegally', they will 'package it and all your info and send it to the feds'. It isn't spyware if you partner with the spies. This was just part of the clickbait fearmongering that spread across various news and conspiracy sites before W10's release. From what I recall, it was to do the content clauses surrounding OneDrive/Office 365 (ie, you can't use OneDrive to host your illegally acquired content) that people somehow assumed would apply to their local documents. Microsoft made the privacy policy wording a lot clearer after that and have said numerous times that they really don't give a damn about your local files. > Microsoft decided to go into the data business with Win10. The advertising subsystem in W10 is actually pretty well isolated to the Windows Store and your Bing web searches, and it doesn't involve your personal information (just keyword/demographic based targeting). Your telemetry data isn't used for adverts. Microsoft Ads as a whole doesn't really make a ton of money for Microsoft so they don't invest a lot into it.
- som33 6y agoNot a conspiracy, UWP games that are cracked stop working on windows update. So they are definitely taking over your machine and monitoring whether you are using "unlicensed" software, that was the whole point of forcing an internet connection, so they could forcibly change files/api's and break any software that had been cracked. You are oblivious, The last 23 years of software since the rise of the internet has been theft on a mass scale which started with PC games in the 90's, there has been a war on software ownership that started with PC games... Ultima online, everquest, guild wars 1 and world of warcraft were all just regular RPG's reprogrammed client server to deny the public ownership and when the public fell for it because it is computer illiterate, that lead us to STEAM in 2004. Steam, uplay, origin, are all bids to lock down the PC as a platform and remove control of software from the end user. We used to get level editors in all AAA games, the last 20 years has seen a giant move towards locked down / stolen games. The entire software industry is celebrating the publics stupidity and update of "software you don't own nor control". The latest version of trackmania is being pushed as a "subscription to software you never get". AKA they never give you the game files. The whole thing is a scam and can only exist in a world of people who are gullible and idiotic. MS and intel and AMD are forcing new versions of CPU's not to work with old versions of windows like windows 7 / 8 via driver starvation. Nvidia's videocards have only drivers for windows 10, no windows 7/8 drivers at all. https://www.theverge.com/2016/1/16/10780876/microsoft-windows-support-policy-new-processors-skylake https://www.theverge.com/2016/1/16/10780876/microsoft-window... Read the industry briefs in the push towards total software lockdown: https://tifca.com/wp-content/uploads/2019/09/ClienttoCloud_Vision_V2.pdf https://tifca.com/wp-content/uploads/2019/09/ClienttoCloud_V...