7 ms·
I was only half-serious, but I'll elaborate it into a serious argument anyway. Allowing insider trading will create asymmetric information in the stock market,
by nostrademons 16y ago
I was only half-serious, but I'll elaborate it into a serious argument anyway.
Allowing insider trading will create asymmetric information in the stock market, and that risks creating a "market for lemons" type situation and reducing liquidity. Say that insiders are allowed to trade whenever they want, on whatever information they have. As an outside investor without that information, I should then assume that I will get a raw deal on any trade that I make. The rational action, then, is to avoid trading that stock at all. Even if there're initially lots of non-insiders to trade with, they are all making the same economic calculation, and will come to the same conclusion. Hence, anyone rational will leave the market, and the only people left will be those with inside information, creating a self-fulfilling prophecy. That defeats the whole point of a public stock market.
When you think about economics, you can't stop at first-order effects. The immediate effect of insider trading may be to increase the speed with which information gets to the market, but the long-term effect is to destroy the market itself, as every participant then has an incentive not to trade.
Anyway, the ironic part of my original comment is that I'm actually not an outsider by most people's POV. I can think of a number of people that would pay good money for upcoming Google product releases, were it not illegal (and grounds for firing). So in strictly personal terms, I'd stand to benefit quite a bit from legalized insider trading, but in academic terms, it'd destroy the system that generally works pretty well.