3 ms·
The previous code of conduct was not popular; it says so in TFA. I have been one of those people disaffected by the previous code of conduct, the "virtual hugs
by dijit 6y ago
The previous code of conduct was not popular; it says so in TFA.
I have been one of those people disaffected by the previous code of conduct, the "virtual hugs" and "no commenting on lifestyle choices such as eating habits" rubbed me very much the wrong way.
The new one is much more prescriptive on behaviours that are encouraged, much like the hackernews guidelines.
- loeg 6y ago> I have been one of those people disaffected by the previous code of conduct, the "virtual hugs" and "no commenting on lifestyle choices such as eating habits" rubbed me very much the wrong way. Please don't be disingenuous about the old CoC. You can dislike it or disagree with it, but you're taking that example way out of context[1]: > Harassment includes but is not limited to: > ∗ Physical contact and simulated physical contact (e.g., textual descriptions like "∗hug∗" or "∗backrub∗") without consent or after a request to stop. It's a problem when people don't want you to be doing it, and you do it to them anyway. Much like it would be a problem in the real world. [1]: https://web.archive.org/web/20200108075747/https://www.freebsd.org/internal/code-of-conduct.html https://web.archive.org/web/20200108075747/https://www.freeb...
- zozbot234 6y ago> ∗ Physical contact and simulated physical contact (e.g., textual descriptions like "∗hug∗" or "∗backrub∗") without consent or after a request to stop. Good to know that I'm still 100% free to slap people around a bit with a large trout[0], and that this will not violate the CoC. But it seems weird and perhaps backwards that trout-whacking is OK, while a common polite remark (if perhaps not in a technical context) like ∗hugs∗ is discouraged. [0] Virtually, of course. See https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Trout_slap https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Trout_slap
- loeg 6y agoThis is either a reading comprehension issue or another disingenuous attack. Please refer to the quoted excerpt, "includes but is not limited to."
- michaelmrose 6y agoInstead of being insulting and taking offense work on refining your sense of humor. Life is too short to be so humorless.
- loeg 6y agoThere's a time and a place for jokes, and discussion of sexual harassment isn't it.
- michaelmrose 6y agoPeople joke about death in the singular, natural disasters that kill thousands, and the extinction of the human race but this is the matter so serious humor must be absent?
- michaelmrose 6y agoWhen someone actually touches you it infringes on your rights in a way that reading the text hug cannot not to mention the natural concern for your physical safety. In the mostly imaginary world of serial virtual huggers it seems reasonable that conduct would fall under say sexual harassment or be fixed by blocking people. It's actually nothing like real world touching at all.
- tptacek 6y agoThis is a weird hill to die on. Continuing to send "=hug=" messages to someone who has told you that doing so makes them uncomfortable is very creepy behavior. It'd be grounds for discipline most places I've worked. I understand not wanting a CoC that spells this out, because we're all adults and shouldn't need to be told not to send creepy messages to team members. But I can't understand defending the behavior on the merits.
- michaelmrose 6y agoMaking your document the target of ridicule does no realistic good while undermining its effectiveness.
- nyanpasu64 6y ago> without consent or after a request to stop. Hugging someone after they tell you to stop is obviously creepy. Is hugging someone without asking permission first bad too?
- michaelmrose 6y agoPresumably actually hugging someone is subject to societal, cultural, interpersonal norms. People at least try to discern in which situations and for which people its likely OK to initiate a hug. Then you watch how people react and modify your behavior accordingly. If you mistakenly thought it was OK and instead of warmth you perceive discomfort or a deer in the headlights look you would abort. If in doubt just don't do it or ask. In real context this complexity is simplified by the presence of social cues, body language, facial expressions, the fact that more people are apt to share the same set of social norms. None of these things are available in text. Fortunately typing hug at someone doesn't involve actually touching their body. It provides basically none of the meaningful benefits of actually hugging someone. No real social closeness. No actual meaningful comfort. It also provides none of the risks to the persons safety or their person. This is probably why typing 'hug' is the providence of 12 year old girls and including it in a code of conduct makes projects the subject of ridicule.
- dijit 6y agoI guess this is open to your reading. I read that statement with the emphasis on without consent meaning I must first gather consent before saying something. That strikes me as asinine because you can verbally say many things which incite anxiety that aren't at all related to the examples given. I don't think it's a bad faith interpretation, it's just an interpretation I took- and my interpretation is as valid as yours unless you say that I am somehow less valid than you are, which is hugely offensive. If I am reading it wrong and at least 35% of others are reading it "wrong" then perhaps the issue is with the words used.
- microcolonel 6y agoHearing that from somebody gives me hope. A trend I had been seeing over the past few years was the introduction of codes of conduct to communities that were basically peaceable, each just as often followed by a torrent of petty tyranny as by a continued peace.
- syshum 6y agoLargely because they are ideological Trojan Horse's pretending to be a rational neutral code of conduct.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]