3 ms·
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Racism https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Racism : > Today, some scholars of racism prefer to use the concept in the plural racisms, i
by eesmith 6y ago
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Racism https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Racism :
> Today, some scholars of racism prefer to use the concept in the plural racisms, in order to emphasize its many different forms that do not easily fall under a single definition. ...
> Garner (2009: p. 11) summarizes different existing definitions of racism and identifies three common elements contained in those definitions of racism. First, a historical, hierarchical power relationship between groups; second, a set of ideas (an ideology) about racial differences; and, third, discriminatory actions (practices).
Your "believing that people of some other race are inferior" falls under the second of those three.
But compare your "nothing to do with laws or power structure" with "historical, hierarchical power relationship". Clearly there are different definitions.
On the same page:
> Scholars also commonly define racism not only in terms of individual prejudice, but also in terms of a power structure that protects the interests of the dominant culture and actively discriminates against ethnic minorities. From this perspective, while members of ethnic minorities may be prejudiced against members of the dominant culture, they lack the political and economic power to actively oppress them, and they are therefore not practicing "racism".
Which leads us back to the reason I joined this thread in the first place - that perspective was dismissively summarized earlier as the '"you can't be racist towards white people" mantra.'
- effie 6y agoThe quote says there are different existing definitions of racism. I agree with that statement. I don't agree that your definition of racism is useful to discussion. It is a redefinition that confuses people into false and harmful beliefs, such as the idea that "people of oppressed minority race cannot be racial oppresors" or the idea that "an action/belief against white majority cannot be racist".
- eesmith 6y agoWhile you don't agree with the quote about how the scholarly definition requires an imbalanced power structure. What are the false and harmful beliefs? More specifically, what are some examples of an oppressed minority race becoming racial oppressors while still being subordinate in the power structure? How are they able to oppress with little political and economic power to do the oppression? What are examples of where it's important to say that an action against a white majority is "racist" when we cannot equally well say it's "racially discriminatory" or "racially bigoted" or other terms? Yes, there are many terms with differing definitions. We need only look at the differing definitions and understanding of what "rape" means. (Or the "evolution is only a theory" crowd.) But that doesn't mean (going way back to how I entered this thread) that it's correct to describe this more scholarly-based interpretation as 'the good old "you can't be racist towards white people" mantra'.
- effie 6y ago> what are some examples of an oppressed minority race becoming racial oppressors while still being subordinate in the power structure? If minority is a requirement, then some examples are: 1) Jewish Nazi collaborators killing Jews, 2) Black gangsters killing black people 3) black/latin-american SJW agents manipulating authorities for more discrimination and cancelling of their white enemies. > How are they able to oppress with little political and economic power to do the oppression? In cases 1),3) by having elevated power granted and supported by even more powerful groups. In case 2) they are organized violent people with guns - they have substantial power.
- eesmith 6y ago[I haven't repeated this disclaimer recently enough. "Race" is a sociological construct with no biological meaning.] 1) Apartheid South Africa gave special status to Japanese people - honorary whites. This doesn't mean that the Japanese people could control their own status; it was a special status given to them by the white supremacists who wanted Japanese trade deals. Similarly, your 1) is for people were granted special privileges by the racist Christian Germans because of the services rendered for the racist power structure. But the racist power originated from those Christian Germans, not Jewish Germans. So, great, you've discovered that some black slaves avoided whippings by helping their white slave masters keep the other slaves in line. With as much sarcasm as I can muster: If only those black slaves hadn't been so racist. 2) How is this racism, any more than white gangsters killing white people? So if a black business owner shortchanges a black customer, that's also racism? 3) Are you effing kidding me? Everyone who is outraged at, angry with, or otherwise against the police violence against black people is an SJW. I am an SJW. 60% of Americans believe that ’Racism is built into American society. The assumption of white superiority pervades schools, business, housing, and government.’ according to a recent Yahoo News/YouGov poll. 52% agree that "President Trump is a racist." The majority of Americans are SJWs. If you are not outraged .. why not? Drop the nonsensical "SJW" rhetorical label. Demand social justice and equality. Now, back to 3) By "example" I don't mean some abstract story. Because I remember the lying stories Republicans used about black welfare queens in order to harness good old American racism to shrink our social safety net. "Agents"? How sinister! You know you could have left it as "SJWs", right? Your terms have been so over-used by right-wing extremists that they have acquired new meanings. Your "more discrimination" comes across like those people who insist that "feminism" means not "gender equality in the public sphere" but wrongly that "women should be in charge, and men should be hated." While your "cancelling" bring to mind all those people who think "cancel culture" means "no one expressing bigoted ideas should ever have to face consequences."