3 ms·
Haiku looks like an interesting project. I like the concept and the consistent design, but ... it is still missing one critical feature ... a viable business mo
by jqpabc123 6y ago
Haiku looks like an interesting project. I like the concept and the consistent design, but ... it is still missing one critical feature ... a viable business model.
Linux is an example of what to expect without this critical piece. Decades of manhours from some of the best and brightest, millions of lines of code ... and a miniscule marketshare on the desktop.
- mulmen 6y agoThere are many successful businesses built on top of Linux. The install base of Linux is small on desktops but it's the most common OS on all other platforms.
- jqpabc123 6y agoYes, I know. Linux is most successful where only a shell interface is required. But this is not what Haiku is about.
- zlynx 6y agoCars. Airplanes. Space capsules. Coffee machines. Linux shows up everywhere. With a GUI.
- jqpabc123 6y agoDedicated, embedded, custom made, single purpose GUIs where the OS is buried so deep that most users will never find it. Again, not what Haiku is about.
- cmrdporcupine 6y agoyour phone is a 'custom made' 'single purpose' GUI? android is linux
- jqpabc123 6y agoLinux was a starting point --- that it's gone well beyond,
- cmrdporcupine 6y agohuh? no, it's still a linux kernel the user space isn't an ubuntu or redhat but the kernel is linux
- outworlder 6y agoIt's still Linux. Please stop moving goalposts. Either Linux is successful, or it isn't. Android proves that it is successful on cellphones (which likely means it's the most used Operating System in the whole planet). It's is successful in server applications. It is successful in cars. Consumer devices. And so on. Just because you don't see many people doing their Excel spreadsheets on their Linux PCs doesn't mean it is not successful. Also, Linux started with NO business model. It started out as a "fun" project – and because the Unix operating systems at the time _had_ a business model, which made them cost prohibitive for many people.
- jqpabc123 6y agoPlease stop moving goalposts. I think we need to re-examine the playing field here. Correct me if I'm wrong but Haiku appears aimed strictly at the desktop as a general purpose OS. Cellphones, servers and embedded systems are all out of it's league --- and thus the success of Linux in these areas is not really relevant to the topic at hand.
- cmrdporcupine 6y agoSure, I think people are just objecting to the implication that Linux as an OS had a 'business model' or 'commercialization' problem; in the very early days (I was there) this was the case ... except it was all mostly being done for fun. But these days... it's just everywhere. It's the lingua franca OS for almost all hardware, for better or for worse. And it certainly wasn't targeted originally for cell phones, etc. And it arguably isn't best suited for it. The unix perimission and user model and file system structure etc make little sense there. But somehow it ended up there. Arguably a finely tuned single user system makes more sense for those types of system. so who knows... maybe Haiku or something like it has a future there. I doubt it, as I think of Haiku more of a lovely retro computing project... but it's somewhat conceivable. I mean... former Be engineer Travis Geiselbrecht was behind the early days of Haiku and he's now key behind Fuchsia. So there's some cross polination into that kind of ecosystem anyways.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- Koshkin 6y agomacOS usage share is also small (4.9% according to Wikipedia).
- jqpabc123 6y agoSmall but still significantly more popular and vibrant on the desktop than Linux --- due to it's business model.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- cmrdporcupine 6y agoApple was in a financial free-fall until they had success with the iPod and then the iPhone. The desktop/laptop business model isn't anything to brag about. It's a low margin business that isn't nearly as important to Apple as its smart phones.
- cmrdporcupine 6y agoAndroid is a Linux distribution. It's the most popular phone operating system. It is shipped on millions and millions of devices. It has about 80% of the smartphone market share. Desktop computers are a declining segment. Slightly over half of all browsing is done from a smartphone. Linux's lack of success in the desktop segment is probably not of much relevance anymore. On top of that, the server market is mostly Linux. So, no, contrary to what you're saying... Linux is a runaway commercial and business success. It took a while to get here, but here we are.
- danans 6y ago> Desktop computers are a declining segment. Slightly over half of all browsing is done from a smartphone. Desktop workstations are indeed a niche now, but laptops and convertibles aren't going anywhere soon. Touchscreen only devices are seriously limited to this day for a lot of creative/productive work work.
- cmrdporcupine 6y agoI don't like touchscreen devices and prefer desktop computers, too. But I'm not most consumers, apparently. Because mobile is where people are spending most of their time. And they're spending it on linux.
- danans 6y agoI think that mobile devices haven't taken as much time away from desktop computing as they have from other areas of life, like watching sitcoms, or talking on the phone. Those were spans of time that desktop computing never usurped - despite trying - and at some point all the growth was mobile, and yes, to your point, that's absolutely mostly Linux via Android. At least on my case a lot of my time on mobile is communication apps and reading things like HN. Desktop time is of course work, but also personal planning and more complex personal tasks.
- cmrdporcupine 6y ago
- agildehaus 6y agoIt's not a business. Why does there have to be a business model?
- jqpabc123 6y agoIt doesn't need one --- as long as it only aspires to be another hobbyist OS with a miniscule desktop user base.
- Apocryphon 6y agoWhat about BSD?
- agildehaus 6y agoIt aspires to be something the developers enjoy hacking on and using, which is the very reason it exists at all. Why you seem to think it needs to be more than that is puzzling. I'm sure the developers would love for it to be more than that, but there's a limit to what can be done and it's ASTONISHING what they have done.
- slantyyz 6y agoI'm pretty sure there is no business model. I see Haiku as a labour of love.