5 ms·
"English started out as German." Can we not do better than this? This is factually incorrect. I'm sure the author knows better, and just thought readers weren'
by cmrdporcupine 6y ago
"English started out as German."
Can we not do better than this? This is factually incorrect. I'm sure the author knows better, and just thought readers weren't "smart" enough to be able to understand "English is part of the Germanic language family" or "German and English are related", but instead this is just ... no... I don't think I'm being pedantic by complaining about this... But this is like saying that "Spanish started out as French" or "Romanian started out as Italian"
German refers to the language descended from Old High Franconian. English is descendended from the Anglo-Saxon dialects, the languages of peoples who invaded Britain from the western coast of what is now Denmark and the northeast coast of what is now the Netherlands. And then modified with a whole bunch of old Norse influence from Danish and Norwegian invaders. And then with a whole bunch of Old Norman French influence... etc.
If you look for a _modern_ Germanic language that English is most closely related to it would be the low Germanic languages, low Saxon, Frisian, even Dutch more so than German proper. Low and high refers to altitude -- not class or prestige or anything -- the "high" German languages are those that underwent a softening/changing sound shift which came out of the highlands in southern Germany. English, like Dutch, never underwent that sound shift. Hence we say "School" with a "k" for the sch instead of a soft "sch" like in German.
- monadic2 6y agoWhat’s the misunderstanding you’re trying to avoid with this distinction?
- _emacsomancer_ 6y agoDo you descend from your cousin? No. You're related, and thus share a common ancestor.
- monadic2 6y agoSure, but who believes english comes from modern german? The OP is laying out a strawman of confusion. The article certainly does not make this claim. It’s being pulled from the OP’s ass with no context for a dopamine hit. Edit: removed accidental condemnation of sodomy.
- _emacsomancer_ 6y agoI regularly teach a historical linguistics course. Despite my repeatedly telling my students that Germanic is not the same as German (it's easier in German, where the distinction is clearer: Germanisch vs Deutsch), and that English doesn't come from German, a surprisingly high percentage still end up thinking that English comes from German. So, the Strawman is realer than one would like, albeit still lacking a brain.
- shitgoose 6y agoYou are probably right, but the original article is more of a "freestyle". It is entertaining and engaging. Conflating (deliberate or not) of cousins and ancestors is a small price to pay to keep the reader on the subject. [pardon my English, I am sure you will find enough to critisize]
- cmrdporcupine 6y agoIt was pretty entertaining, sure. English in all its phases is a fascinating language. Hence why I hate to see it reduced to some kind of debased German :-) I like German, too. I wish I spoke more of it. What's interesting is the gap of time between our last written Old English (Anglo-Saxon) and the time that Middle English was written down. In-between is a couple hundred years of time where the aristocracy spoke and wrote in Old Norman French. Interesting things happened phonetically in that time but we know little of it.
- _emacsomancer_ 6y agoIt would be pretty easy to say something like "Go far enough back, and English and German (and Dutch &c.) were the same language...."
- monadic2 6y agoIs that not true? Certainly you can find a period of time when populations in both England and Saxony spoke mutually intelligible tongues. This confusion seems to arise out of a deliberate misinterpretation of your quote out of bad faith, not any semantic misunderstanding of the past. If you believe this isn’t true you’re wandering into a territory of objectively demarcated language and dialect classification to little benefit. Pedagogically useful I’m sure, but to what semantic end? Hell I thought this was the type of problem linguistics intended to solve.
- diffrinse 6y agoBesides presenting the wrong graph of relations in the language remarked upon already, the statement gives the sense to someone uninformed that modern German is a pretty old language.
- monadic2 6y agoGerman is a pretty old language, just like most languages. English didn’t just pop into being in the sixteenth century either. This is just semantic handwringing that doesn’t add any understanding to the idea that english is a germanic language, which again does not imply that modern english comes from modern german. So again, why does this apparent misunderstanding matter? It certainly doesn’t detract from the article that a less precise colloquialism was used.
- cmrdporcupine 6y agoNo, it's literally as incorrect as saying Italian came from French. When in fact both just came from Vulgur Latin. Both share a common ancestor. A lot further back than the 16th century. At the time that the branch that became English came into existence, German didn't exist either. It was just Frankish, or Alemannic. At the time the Angles Saxons and Jutes left the continent, what eventually became German looked like this: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bergakker_inscription https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bergakker_inscription And it was already a separate language from the Angles' language
- dntbnmpls 6y ago> "English started out as German." Full context: "English started out as German. Old English, also called Anglo-Saxon, really is a foreign language, and requires serious study. I don't think an anglophone can learn to read it with mere tricks." > Can we not do better than this? Can you just stop copying and pasting things out of context? > But this is like saying that "Spanish started out as French" or "Romanian started out as Italian" It's more like saying spanish started as latin given the context. > English is descendended from the Anglo-Saxon dialects So english started out as german?
- cmrdporcupine 6y agoUm, no, English did not start out as German. Did you even read what I wrote? German and English started from a common ancestor yes. About at least 2500 years ago, probably. But English did not start out as German any more than German started out as English. They are cousins. The ancestor they share in common is/was not called German. By anybody.
- dntbnmpls 6y agoUm, yes. "Full context: "English started out as German. Old English, also called Anglo-Saxon, really is a foreign language, and requires serious study. I don't think an anglophone can learn to read it with mere tricks." > Did you even read what I wrote? Yes, I even responded on a point by point basis. Did you read what I wrote? > German and English started from a common ancestor yes It is clear the author was talking about german as in germanic. Hence why he referred to old english and anglo-saxon. Nobody is saying that english came from the modern german language. You sneakily copied one sentence out of context to argue nonsense - that the author claimed english came from modern german. You built up a silly straw man and you got called out. Once again. The author wasn't claiming the modern english language came from modern german. But the language that english descended from was german. Just like the anglo-saxon people were german. As in germanic. Okay?
- cmrdporcupine 6y agoIt's not my fault you have a "sneaky" reading where somehow "German" = "Germanic". Don't accuse me of being the sneaky one. You're distorting what I wrote _and_ what the original article author wrote. That's not in the article at all. And yes, I read the full context. So you either misunderstand what Germanic is, or you're choosing to read the author's sentence substituting "Germanic" for German, or you're being deliberately hostile. ... Socrates is a man, all men are mortal, socrates is mortal... but not all men are socrates.