3 ms·
I read this article very carefully, and I still have not yet seen any confirmation here or prior that rules out a semi-custom solution involving the other x86 v
by bob1029 6y ago
I read this article very carefully, and I still have not yet seen any confirmation here or prior that rules out a semi-custom solution involving the other x86 vendor.
Perhaps this is just a game of semantics?
"Its own mac chips" vs "x86+ARM chips co-designed by AMD & Apple, fabricated by TSMC, and slapped with an Apple logo".
From AMD's semi-custom page:
"We are not bound by convention and don’t subscribe to “one-size-fits-all” thinking. We develop customized SOCs leveraging AMD technology including industry-leading x86 and ARM® multi-core CPUs, world-class AMD Radeon® graphics, and multimedia accelerators. We offer the option to further customize each solution to include third-party and/or open market IP or customer designed IP. Discover how you can differentiate with AMD Semi-Custom solutions."
https://www.amd.com/en/products/semi-custom-solutions https://www.amd.com/en/products/semi-custom-solutions
I still cannot see a hard switch to ARM without any HW x86 capability in the mix. The impact to user experience would be very dramatic and the PR would be a nightmare to deal with. The way I see this playing out is that the next gen of Apple hardware provides both an x86 and an ARM stack, with subsequent generations potentially being ARM only (i.e. w/ x86 emulation). There is just too much software investment in the x86 ecosystem at this point. You have to give people a path to migrate peacefully or they will never return. This isn't like prior architecture switches. The impact with PPC->x86 was not even 1/100th what the impact would be today if Apple forced a hard x86->ARM switch.
All of that said, I can understand why they would want to keep something like this under wraps until T-minus 0.
- thomascgalvin 6y agoWhat you said makes sense, particularly: > There is just too much software investment in the x86 ecosystem at this point. But I don't have any confidence in Apple's leadership anymore. There was a lot of software investment in 32 bit apps, too, and they merrily launched a nuke at that entire library. Do I think they're going to drop X86? No. But is it a possibility? Absolutely.
- regularfry 6y agoI think there's a better-than-average chance that they'd cut compatibility just to show that they're capable of doing so. They'd probably get away with it, too.
- scarface74 6y agoHave you been following Apple for the last two decades? They have always dropped legacy support - 68K, Classic MacOS, PPC, 32 bit software. Keeping compatibility forever has its own drawbacks - maintenance, performance, increased vulnerability surface, regression testing etc.
- timw4mail 6y ago68K support on the hardware side happened in OS 8.6. On the software side, it wasn't dropped until the Classic environment was. Legacy support has deteriorated more rapidly recently, it seems.
- scarface74 6y agoThe last 32 bit Mac was shipped in 2006. They announced they weren’t going to port Carbon to 64 bit about a decade ago. Was there really any great surprise that you shouldn’t be writing 32 bit software in 2015 let alone 2019?
- timw4mail 6y agoI think the bigger surprise is that the first Intel Macs were 32bit and/or had 32bit EFI. My gripe is more with how long they supported PowerPC on the Intel side.