4 ms·
The first launch is 40 minutes in and is entirely realistic. The second launch is with the Ranger spaceship from the water planet, 1h:15 minutes in. The fact th
by jiggawatts 6y ago
The first launch is 40 minutes in and is entirely realistic. The second launch is with the Ranger spaceship from the water planet, 1h:15 minutes in. The fact that you sat through over an hour of this movie and it felt like 20 minutes shows that it completely engrossed you to the point that you failed to notice the passage of time.
But anyway, this is far too harsh a criticism for one of the most realistic science fiction movies in ages, possibly ever.
Here's a short list of things you'll not see in any other science fiction movie, except for rare exceptions like 2001 A Space Odyssey, and certainly not in combination:
* No sound in space. The explosion caused by Dr Mann is not only silent, but this silence is used to fantastic dramatic effect. I got goosebumps! One of the best moments in cinema I've ever experienced.
* Spinning the spaceship to create artificial gravity. No gravity plating in this movie that can be turned on and off with a switch.
* Having to hibernate for the voyage to just Saturn, which is realistic because any such journey at sub-light speeds would take years even with advanced rocket technology.
* Correctly spherical wormholes with accurate rendering of the light distortion.
* Correctly rendered black holes.
* Correct demonstration of time distortion as caused by said black holes.
* The spaceships are physical models and the lighting effects of space and planets as seen through the windows are entirely realistic. They're a perfect match for videos taken on the ISS or on the Apollo missions.
* An incredible atmosphere that makes you feel, down to the very marrow of your being, the unspeakable isolation that deep space travel implies. Of being light years from Terra. Of being truly, utterly isolated to a level that is beyond all human reason. Dr Mann's plight made me have existential dread like no movie ever has.
In the entire movie, the only things I fault were:
1) It's not unreasonable for the Ranger to or the Lander to take off from a planet surface, as long as the gravity is significantly lower than Earth. Mars-like gravity would allow this just fine. What is unreasonable is for the Ranger to travel through a gravity well that could cause the level of time distortion they experienced. This makes for a fun plot element though, so whatever.
2) While they had a realistic wormhole and black hole, they "had" to put a tunnel into the wormhole for Hollywood reasons. People expect a tunnel. There is no tunnel, the second you enter you're already on the other side and the spherical exit starts receding behind you.
3) The floating solid clouds are a bit silly.
... and that's about it for the criticism. Meanwhile, I can heap praise on this movie for hours. In my book it's a nearly perfect movie, and anyone who criticises it is revealing more about their own flaws, about their own inability to suspend disbelief, and their own inability to accept anything that is less than absolute perfection than any flaw in the movie.
(It also has amazing music. And time travel. And awesome robots. And...)
- Udik 6y agoOk, so: 1) there is a plant blight that attacks all plants (pretty unrealistic), and instead of getting rid of it they build a giant space rocket to colonize worlds many light years away, leaving everyone else to die. Completely absurd. 2) Somehow they also know how to get rid of the blight at least in specimens, because otherwise they'd be bringing it with them. Also pretty absurd. 2.1) you wonder why instead of launching giant capsules in space full of plants without the blight, they wouldn't just build giant airtight greenhouses on earth? 3) They plan and build an interstellar mission all by themselves, in a world where there are supposedly no high-tech companies or science left. 4) they enroll as the lead of the mission someone that hasn't trained for at least ten years (I believe they leave soon after). 5) they have highly advanced ai robots, which they use to produce sarcasm. They could just throw some in space: no suit or capsule needed- do your job and report. 6) the rocket launches from inside the nasa office building. Random adventures with CGI on alien planets and very human squabbles follow- here we're in full adventure mode where people take off and land on planets without rockets, and nothing really interesting happens from the scientific point of view. The few accuracies you mention (no sound in space, spinning spaceship, etc.) are just copied over from 2001. The rest is decent cgi and a lot of hype about black holes physics being correct. 7) then there's black hole and love silliness. 8) the hero rejoins the cute lady in dire need of company- she surely won't reject his love. And I thought we were in woman empowerment era!
- jiggawatts 6y ago> instead of getting rid of it Like we can get rid of Coronavirus? Escaping to space for them is a form of quarantine, or a "green zone" to escape from the "red zone" of Earth. There's no hope of disinfecting a planet. > Somehow they also know how to get rid of the blight at least in specimens, It's easy to disinfect small things, like a handful of seeds. > you wonder why instead of launching giant capsules in space full of plants without the blight, they wouldn't just build giant airtight greenhouses on earth? The implication is that they're already doing everything they can, but that the Blight will eventually leave Earth about as habitable as Mars, so at that point you may as well go somewhere else. > They plan and build an interstellar mission all by themselves It's mentioned several times that the staff of hundreds are NASA (logos everywhere), and that the spaceships are largely the same that Coop used to fly before the Blight. That's why they want him specifically, he's a trained pilot with previous experience. There's also a lot of technology left, such as AIs with apparent sentience. These are common enough to be used to pilot harvesters! > hasn't trained for at least ten years They skipped over the simulator time, it's a movie, not a documentary. What would you rather have as a pilot: Someone who's never flown before or someone who has? > They could just throw some in space: no suit or capsule needed- do your job and report. The AIs may not be as good as humans. > the rocket launches from inside the nasa office building. It was explained that this is a launch silo, the same as the type used by ballistic missiles. This is standard stuff. The reasoning is that they're working largely in secret, because their work is unpopular with the public. PS: The American public being this rabidly anti-scientific is entirely plausible! cough5G conspiracy nutscough. > Random adventures with CGI on alien planets and very human squabbles follow They're mankind's only hope and under incredible stress. Their friend dies. They're not exactly going to go about their business like emotionless robots. Also, drama is entertaining. This is a movie! Adventures are also entertaining. What's wrong with adventure!? > Then there's black hole Which was awesome to see in a Hollywood movie. > love silliness. Probably the most out-there part of the movie, but so what? If they didn't put this in there, like you said, they could have just sent robots. Look at it like this: Have you ever heard stories of lost dogs that travel a thousand miles to get back to their home? Because they love their owners and are desperate to get back, no matter the hardship? Coop is like that dog, his love for his daughter is the thing that helps him find the way home. It's sappy, but whatever. > the hero rejoins the cute lady in dire need of company- she surely won't reject his love. Agreed, the mandatory relationship is a trope too many. So clearly it's a crap movie that nobody should watch. We should stick to the sci-fi classics like Transformers.