3 ms·
Thurston's answer is obviously well meaning and trying to breath inspiration into people who are pursuing maths as a discipline, but it should be observed anyon
by roenxi 6y ago
Thurston's answer is obviously well meaning and trying to breath inspiration into people who are pursuing maths as a discipline, but it should be observed anyone taking him at his word without context will be led astray. It isn't useful guidance for a young aspiring mathematician because it is generic, contains nothing actionable and not even a clue on how to judge a successful/failed state as they move through life.
Even "your name will go down in history if you consistently find patterns in daily life that other people can't see" would probably be more useful advice to the next Euler or Gauss.
> The product of mathematics is clarity and understanding.
Mathematics is clarity and understanding of mathematical objects which is a very small subset of the things that most people seek when they go looking for clarity and understanding. Anyone looking for clarity and understanding in the abstract is better off starting their search in the Psychology or possibly the Philosophy departments.
I don't think he was being arrogant with that quote, but I do think that it is the perspective of someone who has spent so much time looking at maths they might have lost track of all the social manoeuvring that is what satisfies most humans. In my case I'd rather have a deep understanding of what someone is saying to me than of Fermat's Last Theorem - communication abilities tends to be more of a bottleneck to satisfaction than abstraction abilities. Even in Thurston's answer, he is alluding to the fact that communicating with other mathematicians is as important to him as understanding abstract concepts.
> follow your heart and your passion. Bare reason is likely to lead you astray
This is lousy advice. Following your passions only works for people lucky enough to have productive passions. A lot of people are passionate about eating good food - if they want to be productive they will need a plan other than following their passions.
- orbifold 6y agoThere is a very real sense in which working in mathematics can be suffering. I feel like any research mathematician sooner or later has that feeling. Because you will be confronted with your limitations and weaknesses eventually. So I think this a shared experience that is the implicitly understood background of his answer. What I took away from Thurstons answer was a way to deal with that suffering. I eventually decided that I did not really want to continue in a research mathematics direction, but for a while his answer really inspired me.
- auggierose 6y agoI think Thurston's answer is absolutely to the point. If you are passionate enough about good food, you probably have a great shot at becoming a famous chef. I agree though that it is very dangerous advice: most people are just not passionate enough about something, but mistake fondness for passion. I'd say that applies to your "good food" example. But on the other hand, for truly passionate people it is very dangerous NOT to follow this advice. > The product of mathematics is clarity and understanding Somewhere else Thurston qualifies this in a recursive definition of mathematics that is bootstrapped with numbers and geometrical objects. I'd say in the age of the computer this qualification becomes less and less necessary: there are other things than numbers and geometrical objects that are of interest (for example distributed file systems). So more and more things are becoming amenable to clarity and understanding, if we try hard enough. I think a lot of things in computing could use a good helping of clarity and understanding.
- jgwil2 6y agoLove the phrase, "mistake fondness for passion." Thanks!