4 ms·
Very interesting article, but set up against a strange straw man. First, the usefulness of a full page of text for critically analyzing a font is obviously ext
by crazygringo 6y ago
Very interesting article, but set up against a strange straw man.
First, the usefulness of a full page of text for critically analyzing a font is obviously extremely useful for type designers looking for flaws to fix, or perhaps a national newspaper or magazine selecting a new body type that must be absolutely flawless. This is indeed a great text for proofing fonts.
But "quick brown fox" was never intended for proofing fonts. When the author says pangrams are "singularly useless" for that, he's right, but they're very good for something else.
Mainly, browsing fonts in a catalog to get the full personality at a single glance, on a single line. Above all what kind of "a", "e", "f", "g", "j", "l", "t", and "w" it has, since these (in non-italic) generally have the most variation. To check if there are any letters the font does something "weird" with. And just get an overall basic sense of look and spacing.
So setting the paragraphs he comes up with, as a replacement for pangrams, just feels like the entirely wrong way to frame it.
(All that said, I have insane respect for the man -- his designs set the absolute top bar.)
- noizejoy 6y agoMmmhh - I’m not a font designer, but just someone who chooses fonts for websites on a regular basis. And I’ve often found myself frustrated about not finding a good representative page of text, allowing me to evaluate fonts better than just single sentences. So this is a hugely welcome addition to my toolkit - definitely replacing pangrams for me and big thanks to Mr. Hoefler for making it publicly available.
- daxterspeed 6y agoI think the parent argued that both serve a purpose. When you're dealing with a large selection of fonts a small pangram is more useful to help you narrow the list down - until it becomes small enough that you can switch to one of these font proofs to evaluate the final few fonts. Websites like Google Fonts should absolutely use one of these font proofs for the dedicated font pages - or when simply comparing two fonts, but use a shorter pangram when comparing several fonts at once.
- beardyw 6y agoI think there is a general problem of fonts being treated as if they were all equivalent when in reality there are fonts which can only be sanely used as display fonts, and body text fonts which admittedly you might use as both. The computer has lumped them all together in a way a type setter would never do. So, yes, different approaches for different uses. As to choosing a font, having had a typographer, a graphic designer and a book dealer as 3 of my brother's, it is a job which I can hardly find the courage to do. I also regularly wish others shared my self doubt and left it to a professional, or at least just followed conventional wisdom. A font you notice is a bad font.
- eyaeyaeya 6y agoHis or Frere-Jones’?
- cardamomo 6y agoGood question. For those unaware of the spat between the two designers, here's an excellent 2014 article: https://nymag.com/news/features/jonathan-hoefler-tobias-frere-jones-2014-6/ https://nymag.com/news/features/jonathan-hoefler-tobias-frer... In short, Frere-Jones accused Hoefler of intellectual property theft and not honoring the terms of the verbal agreement outlining their business partnership. I'm not sure how the case ended up.
- noizejoy 6y agoApparently it was settled before discovery started [0], so no further details ever came out. [0] https://www.theverge.com/2014/9/29/6868945/the-worlds-biggest-typeface-firm-just-settled-its-lawsuit https://www.theverge.com/2014/9/29/6868945/the-worlds-bigges...
- cardamomo 6y agoThanks for that! I went down the rabbit hole of looking at NY court records.
- mc32 6y agoI’m not a designer or typesetter either and I find that sampling the typeface and font via a simple representative sentence to be helpful. How wide is the “m”, is the “a” single storey or double, αre the legs of the k offset or simple v?
- sildur 6y agoAlso, I would have titled it: “Quick brown fox considered harmful”.
- tobr 6y ago> (All that said, I have insane respect for the man -- his designs set the absolute top bar.) I have insane respect for the typefaces that are sold under his name. Unfortunately, the most iconic designs were taken from his former partner Tobias Frere-Jones, and are now sold without the appropriate credit. That is not worthy of respect.