4 ms·
boggles Seriously, this is about as credible as "Hurricane Katrina was caused by God smiting us for embrace of the gays." I mean, pull out your handy dandy gl
by patio11 16y ago
boggles
Seriously, this is about as credible as "Hurricane Katrina was caused by God smiting us for embrace of the gays."
I mean, pull out your handy dandy globe. Note the positioning of Japan and Chile. Which do you think matters more to their tectonic plates -- ice, or that little blue splotch labeled the Pacific Ocean. (One hesitates to remind the carbon-angers-Gaia crowd of third grade science, but water masses the exact same whether frozen, liquid, or gaseous -- and if the question is local density where "local" is the size of a tectonic plate, when it melts it is one of very few things that gets more dense.)
- btilly 16y agoI mean, pull out your handy dandy globe. Note the positioning of Japan and Chile. Which do you think matters more to their tectonic plates -- ice, or that little blue splotch labeled the Pacific Ocean. I pulled out my globe. I noted that the ice which is melting in Greenland largely winds up as water in the Pacific Ocean, which pushes down on the Pacific plate. Therefore melting ice does change the Pacific Ocean. Obviously global warming is not the cause of earthquakes. But they could be the straw that breaks the camel's back. So an earthquake that otherwise might have happened in 10 years tips over now. If that kind of timeline compression was happening in several places, we'd get an increase in earthquakes. Let's see how big this straw is. Looking at the graph at http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Current_sea_level_rise http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Current_sea_level_rise I note that the level of sea level rise in the last 30 years has been roughly 10 cm. From http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pacific_Plate http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pacific_Plate I note that the Pacific Plate is 103 million square km. That's 0.1 * 103 * 10^6 * (10^3)^2 = 1.03 * 10^13 cubic meters of water. With a mass of about 10^16 kg. Pushing straight down on a plate that over most of its major earthquake faults, including the one that just rocked Japan, is subducting (ie being pushed under nearby plates). I would not have thought of that. But having had it pointed out to me, it does not seem obvious to me that there is no connection. I don't know how likely the connection is, but it I wouldn't mind seeing research on the topic. In the end I consider it about as likely that this is a coincidence, with numbers that look more extreme than chance would seem to explain because earthquakes in one place are correlated with earthquakes in another. So we should tend to get bunches of earthquakes. Incidentally if you go and actually read the linked article, rather than just react to the title, you'll find that this is fairly close to the tone that they take.