4 ms·
> Any catastrophe that happens so close to the point of becoming a multi-planetary civilisation simply wouldn't catch enough species. Unless you're missing som
by naasking 6y ago
> Any catastrophe that happens so close to the point of becoming a multi-planetary civilisation simply wouldn't catch enough species.
Unless you're missing some sort of fundamental serialization of events, like technology A that enables colonization is also so destructive that it wipes them out. Nuclear power could have been an example.
Perhaps we would need to master genetic engineering in order to survive the ravages of long-term space exposure, and that might inevitably lead to an outbreak that wipes out most of the species.
Or perhaps sufficient automation is needed because biological brains are too slow and imprecise, but sufficient intelligence and automation inevitably yields an AI that supplants them.
- stupidcar 6y agoAs I said, we already have technology to colonise space. Not to spread throughout the galaxy, no, but at least to get to multiple places in our solar system. At that point the feasibility of a single event like a genetic accident always occurring and always wiping out the entirety of every species seems unlikely. Not impossible, of course, but my argument wasn't about possibility vs impossibility, but probability.
- naasking 6y ago> Not to spread throughout the galaxy, no, but at least to get to multiple places in our solar system. To get there, yes. Not necessarily to live there. I was saying that we might need to actually engineer ourselves to live in these other environments, and the path to that might itself lead to the great filter.