5 ms·
Constitutionally, Religious Gatherings Must Enjoy the Same Rights as Protests
- mullingitover 6y agoI don't think religious gatherings should be banned explicitly, just that the number of people sharing air indoors needs to be tightly regulated. With the protests, they're at least outdoors and the vast majority are wearing masks. If religious people can meet outdoors and wear masks in the same fashion, have at it.
- mrkstu 6y agoThat's generally the constitutional test- if you are generally regulating things and not singling out religions, you're ok. Now if a particular practice is essential to that religion, you may have to show a compelling government interest in order to force the religion to comply. The problem, of course, is that if the government is explicitly or even implicitly allowing flouting of those rules then the compelling government interest is null and void. Fig leafs like indoors vs outdoors isn't going to cut it.
- fortran77 6y agoAs a person who attends organized religious services several times a week, I can sort of see why the right to protest the Government may take precedence over anything else. It's the one right you really can't touch even in an emergency. That being said, I really appreciated being able to attend a minyan last Shabbos (outdoors, with restrictions).
- washitallaway 6y agoIf the reason for banning minyanim was to prevent loss of life, that same argument can be made for allowing protests, to prevent loss of life.
- requin246 6y agoIn reality though protests are hardly like any other outdoor gathering. Thousands of people are crowded together for hours and shouting (which projects saliva). Anyone can clearly see it is a hotspot for coronavirus transmission. Authorities are allowing (peaceful) protest though because of free speech rights. The same freedoms are not extended to arguably lower risk religious gatherings. Santa Clara county, which has had daily protests, just allowed outdoor-only religious gatherings of 25 people or less last week. They also opened indoor shopping malls in the same order. They’re clearly not treating religious expression like the fundamental constitutional right that it is. It is easy to find similar examples all over the state. When the coronavirus situation stabilizes, the lawyers are going to have a field day.
- HarryHirsch 6y agoCan we maybe give those that are arrested during protests give the same rights that churchgoers enjoy? In church there is a good distance between families and service is quick, but police seem to enjoy locking protesters up in holding cells for far longer than necessary.
- downerending 6y agoThe proper comparison is between law-abiding protesters and law-abiding churchgoers. Yeah, protesters that break the law, especially by committing serious acts of violence or property damage, can expect to spend quite a while in jail. Many would say not nearly long enough.
- HarryHirsch 6y agoYou are committing the same fallacy at Derek Chauvin, who got called to someone passing a possibly fake $20 bill and sat on the suspect's neck until he died. This isn't how it's supposed to work, everyone is supposed to get their day on court and get the lawful punishment. Any protester who is arrested may or may not have caused property damage (most didn't move away when told to, I wonder how many will have their charges dropped), but there is no reason at all not to take name and address quickly and send them on their way. But police seems to enjoy to inflict extrajudicial punishment, which is why no one likes them. They should be treated like Ronald Reagan treated aircraft controllers: fire them all and hire new ones to make a clean sheet.
- AnimalMuppet 6y agoYou seem to be ignoring the "especially by committing serious acts of violence or property damage" part of downerending's comment. Curfew breakers? Sure, they don't need to stay in jail. Arsonists? Those who physically assaulted others? Different story.
- downerending 6y agoThe part you're missing is that protesters breaking the law are 100% aware of that fact and have the opportunity not to do so. We have no idea of whether Floyd was aware of the fact that he was passing a fake $20, if indeed he even was. (I doubt I'd notice a fake $20.) These two situations are not similar. And if you have doubts about protesters causing serious property damage, aggravated assault, and manslaughter if not murder, I suggest you start looking at the many videos available on the web. There are a lot of truly horrible people out there, and they're having a field day right now.
- chkaloon 6y agoChurches are indoors, protests are outdoors typically.
- hackeraccount 6y agoFor what it's worth if someone had sad - "Please have service outside." I think everyone who goes to church would have been happy. That wasn't presented as an option. Frankly to me the idea seems more like after the fact rationalization.