3 ms·
"It's actually the opposite - even a mundane part like the lug bolt you describe will go through several hardening processes, and post-processing for corrosion
by bigiain 16y ago
"It's actually the opposite - even a mundane part like the lug bolt you describe will go through several hardening processes, and post-processing for corrosion resistance. If not, you're asking for a huge failure on a critical part."
That's at least party due to the different design requirements and constraints that mass-produced for-profit engineers work under. That lawnmower wheel screw was specified not purely on the engineering requirements to "hold the wheel on", but on various other important-to-the-company-designing-them-for-sale requirements, probably including things like: use the cheapest fastener that we already keep in stock that'll do the job, use a fastener that will reliably last the length of the warranty period at the lowest cost, use a fastener that's compatible with out existing automated manufacturing tools. On top of that there will have been other decisions already made like "use an existing wheel assembly" and "ensure the mowers packaged size and weight fit in with existing supply chain logistics".
Once designers are freed from existing manufacturing industry constraints, I like to hope that one day we'll download a push-mower design from somewhere like Google Sketchup, where the designers were perfectly happy to "over engineer" critical components and where the design requirements might include ideas like "should last long enough to pass on to your grandchildren", and "will still be able to be repaired at the side of the road with a flatblade screwdriver and a rock".
- nickpinkston 16y agoIf you're arguing against standardization in parts - that's an uphill battle - sure once we have replicators it doesn't matter, but that's futurism. I'm actively fighting for open source hardware and standards, but a big part of this is finding off the shelf components - look at Http://octopart.com for a good example of what this looks like.
- bigiain 16y ago"If you're arguing against standardization in parts" Oh, very much not. I'm more commenting on unnecessary overspecialisation instead. Unnecessary for non-commercial applications anyway - I understand why Apple chooses to put difficult-to-use fasteners in their products, if for no other reason than to minimise fraudulent warrant claims, but there's a whole different set of motivations if designers are going to use the equivalent of "open source" for digitally reproducible home-fab ready "object" files.