3 ms·
A protest is a political stunt. That seems to be an essential part of what it means to have a protest. And at risk of being too on topic and reading the articl
by roenxi 6y ago
A protest is a political stunt. That seems to be an essential part of what it means to have a protest.
And at risk of being too on topic and reading the article, the issue is that the gloom-and-doom arguments that a lockdown is necessary and correct have been well and truly rejected by the activist wings of politics, and implicitly by a large portion of the commenting-class of journalists. And business. And possibly the public at large. They clearly don't agree.
- caconym_ 6y agoOh, crap! I forgot that I can ignore context and nuance—and even redefine words and terms at will—to win arguments with zero-effort pedantic nonsense! What have I been doing, arguing in good faith all this time? Was the civil rights movement a political stunt? I think I'm rolling my eyes so hard over here that they might fly out of my head. Call it what you want, anyway. I don't care. > the issue is that the gloom-and-doom arguments that a lockdown is necessary and correct have been well and truly rejected by the activist wings of politics, and implicitly by a large portion of the commenting-class of journalists. And business. And possibly the public at large. They clearly don't agree. This is an outrageous simplification and IMO outright misrepresentation of a very complex issue. Where I live, where there are big protests with general neutral-to-positive public sentiment toward them, the majority of people have been taking the public health advice re: COVID-19 very seriously. I'd be very wary of suggesting that my own personal perception does or does not match with the country at large, and I think you should too, especially if you're unwilling to acknowledge the nuance of the issues at stake and/or the reality of racial oppression and violence in America. Would you run back into a burning building to save a 24-pack of Bud Light? Probably not. Your family dog? Maybe? Your daughter? Probably.
- zests 6y agoWe usually try to keep it a bit more civil here.
- caconym_ 6y agoLast night, while I watched my city's police force (backed by nat'l guard) launch a militarized assault on a crowd that was unequivocally 99.99?% physically nonviolent, my partner was putting her life on the line (with inadequate PPE) in a COVID-19 ward just down the street from the clouds of tear gas. So I hope you'll understand that I see our current situation as complex and nuanced, with very real lives hanging in the balance, and that as a result I have no tolerance for masturbatory, misrepresentative debate club bullshit I've seen a thousand times before. But I'm sorry if my incivility offended you.