2 ms·
It’s a good idea in principle, the problem is that the devil is often in the detail and people can say things that seem broadly like a decent argument while sli
by zepto 6y ago
It’s a good idea in principle, the problem is that the devil is often in the detail and people can say things that seem broadly like a decent argument while slipping in details (whether intentionally or not) that completely reverse the meaning or make the meaning quite different.
This is why cross examination in needed in trials - of course everyone tries to make a plausible argument, so noticing the incongruities is important.
Assuming good faith and cross examining are not mutually exclusive.
- dang 6y agoPointing out, or asking about, incongruities is fine. How one does it makes a difference, as does the intention with which one does it. If you want to call all of that cross-examination, that's fine, but in that case we're using the term differently. The main distinction the guidelines are trying to draw is the one between open exchange and destroying enemies.
- zepto 6y agoThat might actually be a better way of saying it then. I think it’s clearer and more direct and has less of an implication of being overly deferential to bad arguments.