3 ms·
The US has lots of different police forces – city police, county police, state police. Many other countries have more centralised policing with fewer levels. I
by skissane 6y ago
The US has lots of different police forces – city police, county police, state police. Many other countries have more centralised policing with fewer levels. I think, a smaller number of bigger police forces might promote more professionalism, more professional management, oversight by more experienced politicians (state political leaders tend to be more experienced and capable than local political leaders, especially when talking about smaller cities). That would suggest abolishing city-level police forces and merging them into the county-level police force, even abolishing county-level police forces and merging it all into state police.
- sneak 6y agoThe problem is that there is no organization that is incentivized to uncover or investigate police crimes. All other portions of government have cross-checks to stop people breaking the law. The police don't, and cover for one another. There needs to be an organization that has clear and direct incentive to prosecute abuses by the police, that doesn't have a century+ long tradition of violence, selective enforcement, racism, and murder.
- skissane 6y agoThe state of New South Wales (NSW), Australia has a Law Enforcement Conduct Commission (LECC) [1], which is a body legally separate from NSW's law enforcement agencies–NSW Police Force, which is the main state police force; NSW Crime Commission, which specialises in organised crime and other serious crime–and which is tasked with investigating law enforcement misconduct. (In Australia, there is no local law enforcement, only state/territorial/federal.) The LECC doesn't prosecute itself, but can investigate cases and refer them to state prosecutors for prosecution. It isn't perfect, but it is better than nothing. Maybe the US could copy the same idea? (Also, separately from the LECC, there is also an Inspector of the LECC, whose job is to investigate misconduct by the LECC themselves.) [1] https://www.lecc.nsw.gov.au https://www.lecc.nsw.gov.au
- samcodes 6y agoPart of me wants to ask “but who investigates the Inspector of the LECC?” But I’ve dealt with Elixir and I know that supervision trees rarely need to be very deep in practice
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- usrusr 6y agoBut it would seem far more feasible to build an organization like that to oversee one unified police force than to have n tiny organizations to oversee n small local police forces. If you'd try to mix levels (one central org cross-checking n small forces) everybody involved would inevitably confuse their role with a central coordination hierarchy and the original intent would get lost.
- elil17 6y agoFor the FBI, there is such an organization. The FBI Inspector General investigates malpractice committed by FBI officers. However, the scope of their ability to fix problems in the FBI is limited because prosecutors rarely take up cases against law enforcement. They also hold FBI officers accountable by writing reports for congress. Again, the usefulness of this is limited by the unwillingness of Congress to act on this information. (Inspectors General exist for for every federal agency)
- novok 6y agoIt has to be an organization separate from any specific police agency, with prosecutors solely devoted to prosecuting police crimes, complete with their bonuses and careers linked to convictions complete with scummy plea bargaining behavior. There also has to be new crimes of negligence for things like 'body cam turned off' or 'records suddenly missing' and so on.
- jMyles 6y ago> county police This is very, very rare. More frequently, we have county Sheriffs, not police. And their duties are quite distinct; only recently have they come to resemble police. Shrievalty is more concerned with the functioning of the courts: sometimes holding suspects before trial (and maintaining jail facilites), ensuring the security and order of the court, protecting jury members from violent coercion, capturing fugitives, etc. Patrolling and "preventative" enforcement is not a traditional role for the Sheriff.
- skissane 6y agoCountry Sheriffs in the US appear to me to do a lot of policing work. For example, Polk County Sheriff (Florida) seems to be busy arresting people for DUI – https://tampa.cbslocal.com/2020/06/06/sheriff-grady-judd-54-dui-arrests-in-may-by-polk-county-sheriffs-office/ https://tampa.cbslocal.com/2020/06/06/sheriff-grady-judd-54-... Sacramento County Sheriff's (Calfornia) has a homicide bureau – https://www.sacsheriff.com/Pages/Organization/CID/Homicide.aspx https://www.sacsheriff.com/Pages/Organization/CID/Homicide.a... Erie County Sheriff (New York) has a drug squad which regularly carries out undercover buy operations – https://www2.erie.gov/sheriff/index.php?q=narcotics-unit https://www2.erie.gov/sheriff/index.php?q=narcotics-unit Washington County Sheriff (Oregon) has a traffic safety unit – https://www.co.washington.or.us/Sheriff/FightingCrime/Patrols/traffic-safety-unit.cfm https://www.co.washington.or.us/Sheriff/FightingCrime/Patrol... Many US counties have unincorporated areas, in which county sheriffs have full police patrol responsibilities. Often, that authority also extends to incorporated areas (villages/towns/smaller cities) which are too small to have their own police departments and rely on the county for all policing functions.
- pyuser583 6y agoWhere I live, County level officials are the folks who implement state policies. For example XYZ County Department of Family services investigate child abuse for the state. We even have a saying “counties are merely agents of the state.” This is a Midwestern thing. The south has strong, independent counties. The moral is that States, counties, and municipalities aren’t just “levels.” In my state, there really is no state government above the county level (outside the state Capitol that is.) There is an exception for law enforcement: we have state troopers and state department of investigation. Neither are a substitute for local police.
- AmIDev 6y agoI am Indian, so I don't have an idea of the state of the administration/police in USA. However, I disagree that centralization is the solution. Accumulating power in hands of few is how you end up being a pseudo-democracy like India/Brazil/Myanmar. By centralizing the police force, USA might end up might an entire state police force supporting a leader with autocratic tendencies, like what is currently happening in India. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2020_JNU_Attack https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2020_JNU_Attack
- skissane 6y agoIn Australia, there are no local police forces (county or city), only state and federal police. In that sense, Australian police are much more centralised than US police. And yet, I don't think Australian police are overall significantly more corrupt than US police. (Yes, Australian police do have corruption problems; but more than US police does?) Degree of police centralisation is similar between India and Australia. India does have city police departments, but they form part of and are subordinate to the state police, rather than being independent agencies like in the US–as such, the state governments exert more control over them than local governments. And Australian state police forces have local divisions too (Police Districts, Area Commands, etc). Rather than India's police corruption problems being due to police centralisation, I think they are likely due to India's broader corruption problems, whose causes are much more complicated than anything merely to do with the organisation of its police services.