3 ms·
How is that any different than the lawless gangs that have the force of government behind them?
by scarface74 6y ago
How is that any different than the lawless gangs that have the force of government behind them?
- chrisco255 6y agoThere exists a decent real world example of "a tale of two police strategies" in two demographically similar cities: Juarez and El Paso. Juarez and El Paso are situated across from each other along the U.S.-Mexico border. In some ways they are the same city, with many residents traveling across the border each day. Juarez is the second most deadly city in the world, at over 100 murders per 100K population [1]. El Paso has just 3.3 murders per 100K population [2]. The difference is that the police and legal system work better in the U.S. compared to Mexico. In many parts of Mexico, gangs run the streets, and officials are either in bed with gangs or often intimidated by gangs [3]. That's what fills the power vacuum in the absence of effective policing. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_cities_by_murder_rate https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_cities_by_murder_rate [2] https://www.areavibes.com/el+paso-tx/crime/ https://www.areavibes.com/el+paso-tx/crime/ [3] https://apnews.com/231aec4552f040e49095f77968e6345c https://apnews.com/231aec4552f040e49095f77968e6345c
- dehrmann 6y agoThe power of Mexican drug cartels is scary. Someone like El Chapo is essentially above the law. The only reason he's still in prison is because he as extradited to the US.
- dehrmann 6y agoAt least in the case of George Floyd, one of officers was charged with murder, the other three with aiding and abetting, so they're clearly not lawless gangs. We'll see what happens at trial, but this is a fair level of scrutiny for what happened; if police faced charges like this every time one of these deaths happened, they'd be a lot more careful.
- scarface74 6y agoOnly because it was filmed. The entire system tried to cover it up at first from the police force, to the coroner, to the DA. When two police were fired and charged with assault for shoving a 77 year old man. 49 other officers resigned in protest. There are plenty of cases where police acted inappropriately. Like raiding the wrong house and shooting a lady while she was sleeping. https://www.npr.org/2020/05/13/855705278/sleeping-while-black-louisville-police-kill-unarmed-black-woman https://www.npr.org/2020/05/13/855705278/sleeping-while-blac... And nothing happens. The entire system is corrupt.
- dehrmann 6y ago> Only because it was filmed. This is a big reason why I'm in favor of police body cams. In an innocent until proven guilty legal system, it's too easy for people to get off by saying "he lunged at me and I defended myself." > coroner Really? I assume you mean the country medical examiner. He ruled the death a homocide. I think people want there to be a simple explanation like "he was choked," but it was actually pretty complicated because of drugs in his system, underlying heart disease, and covid-19. I honestly think both reports are generally true, and there's enough room for difference of opinion in the exact cause of death that I'm not concerned by the different conclusions.
- corfufilma 6y agoDo you (or others) actually believe this statement, or are you being contrarian to make another point? If you do, what sort of experience / data leads one to believe that policing in western societies are top-line equivalent to the strong-armed lawlessness that exists in many failed states around the globe. Genuinely curious.
- scarface74 6y agoThe data that we have is racial bias in stop and frisk (no evidence of crime before the stop), bias is traffic stops, bias in tickets being issued for the same offense, racial bias in sentencing. Not to mention that almost every case that came to trial against police came about after video came out. Before the video, they tried to cover it up. How many times have we seen recently that when “the few bad apples” were fired and/or charged, “the good cops” objected?