3 ms·
Ask HN: is there an opportunity for a non commercial search engine?
What do you think of the idea of a search engine that does not include results for anything commercial such as products, services or companies? Madness or market opportunity?
The reason I have been thinking about this is because when wikipedia first became popular it was very often the top ranked search result for many searches. Now Wikipedia is rarely on the first page - Google is dominated by commercial interests, whether Google's own interests or that of companies who optimise themselves to the top of the rankings. Google gains nothing commercially from Wikipedia being in search results so it has been algorithmed out.
I was wondering if a non commercial search engine would bring Wikipedia back to the top.
- mw63214 16y agodrop.in - "don't search for stuff. search for inspiration. do it. drop.in" ?
- asanwal 16y agoMost of Google's ad money comes from the commercial searches, i.e., digital camera, diapers, etc. Those are the searches that advertisers bid on and people click Google ads. A "non-commercial" search loses that entire opportunity. So in short, IMO - madness.
- andrewstuart 16y agoNo reason not to have relevant commercial ads on non-commercial organic results.
- asanwal 16y agoSo if I search for "newborn diapers", I will get awesome non-commercial results about the history and science behind diapers from Wikipedia and sponsored ads to the right? And what about a blog with affiliate links? Is that commercial or not? While I know it's fashionable now to talk about Google's demise and craptastic results, this idea seems like a solution looking for a problem. Sorry to rain on el parade but just not feeling it.
- klapinat0r 16y agoIf by madness you imply there's no market for it, I'd disagree. However, the idea isn't new: http://blekko.com/ws/+/about http://blekko.com/ws/+/about
- asanwal 16y agoBlekko hasn't proven there is a market for it. They've got some interesting things going on, some good PR in tech circles and have raised some money but until they show revenue, profit and a sustainable business model, the decision on whether there is a real (or just imagined) market is TBD.
- rick888 16y agoI think you could do it, but unless you are funding it through some other means, it's not going to be able to get very big. What defines Commercial? If I have a website for my side project and I ask for donations, is that considered commercial?