4 ms·
"[AI] would be able to make key decisions faster and more accurately" That's a statement nobody here will have problems to accept right? I expect nobody can t
by SiempreViernes 6y ago
"[AI] would be able to make key decisions faster and more accurately"
That's a statement nobody here will have problems to accept right? I expect nobody can think of any example that makes "more accurately" a problematic claim.
- casefields 6y agoSame stuff we heard with the early self-driving vehicle evangelists. Spoiler. It's much harder than they portrayed.
- nbardy 6y agoI don't think that's the case at all with flight vs vehicles. Autonomous driving is complicated because you have to take into account a wide range of scenarios and wide range of human behaviors, and a complex environment to understand. And then make very fuzzy choices on how to react to those scenarios. Combat is a simpler zero sum game, pick and target and destroy. Based on how AI plays top games right now(Starcraft and Dota), very fast quick reflexes and pin point accuracy of their attacks I think the AI drones are going to crush humans.
- blackoil 6y agoIMO the stakes are different. Often quoted is self driving cars must be 10x safer then humans before society accepts them. For drones we'll take 10% worse performance, we are OK to some extant of misfires particularly in a remote village in a 3rd world country. If drones cost 1/10 of a plane it will be a obvious answer for any general.
- 1e-9 6y agoIt seems like an entirely valid statement. AI can certainly make faster decisions than a human and it can utilize accurate 6DoF calculations and multi-sensor fusion that humans can only roughly approximate in an intuitive way during battle. I'm sure there will still be areas where humans will be better, such as analyzing complex visual information or predicting high-level reasoning of an enemy pilot, but I see human-versus-drone encounters as a clear loser for human pilots in the relatively near term.
- AnimalMuppet 6y agoMaybe. If an adversary is messing with your information feeds, a human might do better at realizing "wait, that's not right" than an AI.