3 ms·
Gas powered model engines are not that unreliable, even for model airplanes. One made it all the way across the atlantic: https://amablog.modelaircraft.org/amam
by GekkePrutser 6y ago
Gas powered model engines are not that unreliable, even for model airplanes. One made it all the way across the atlantic: https://amablog.modelaircraft.org/amamuseum/2017/03/29/transatlantic-model-flight-equipment/ https://amablog.modelaircraft.org/amamuseum/2017/03/29/trans...
Ok, the first 4 were lost but this is a huge journey with limited fuel and bad weather. And navigation was a problem too.
The big benefit of gas powered in larger vehicles is both the easy fast refueling and the higher energy density of fuel. Combustion engines for model airplanes are heavier than their electric counterparts because you can only scale things down so much, you still need to contain a constant fire and the associated pressure.
And in this usecase the slow recharge isn't really an issue anyway. It also makes sense for marketing reasons, being 'green'. Even though if fuel were used, you could probably run this entire company for a year on the fuel a semi truck would burn to drive 100km :) I don't think it would be a bad thing for the environment if a company like this would use fossil fuel, it's still a lot less wasteful than the alternatives.
- giantrobot 6y agoI doubt slow recharge is even an issue since they can just pop in a new charged battery pack and put the depleted one on a charger. With swappable battery packs a drone can be relaunched within minutes.
- baybal2 6y ago> Gas powered model engines are not that unreliable, even for model airplanes. Still incomparable to any other option. Having 1 in 1000 crash chance will disqualify it as a DHL alternative. Putting 2 of them on the drone will surely make it cost more than $500 And putting even the cheapest turbine on it is out of question, unless you talk about toy turbines that are as unreliable as RC piston motors.
- TylerE 6y agoI wonder if a pulse jet (as used on the V-1) would be an option? I've seen hobbyist level plans for them, and a pulsejet requires zero moving parts, so reliability should be excellent. The geometry of the engine does all the work.
- baybal2 6y ago> pulsejet requires zero moving parts, so reliability should be excellent. Valves, and pumps are moving parts too.
- TylerE 6y agoModern pulsejets don't use valves. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Valveless_pulsejet https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Valveless_pulsejet Fuel can be either gravity fed or possibly a pressurized system (e.g. fill the deadspace in the tanks with compressed nitrogen)