3 ms·
> Who knows how many chips that Amazon and Google use for their own servers. No amount I can imagine can pay off for the tapeout on the latest node for them. A
by baybal2 6y ago
> Who knows how many chips that Amazon and Google use for their own servers.
No amount I can imagine can pay off for the tapeout on the latest node for them. All dotcoms taken together make for single digit percentage of wafer output for both Intel, or AMD.
Apple doesn't make money on chips, they make money off their devices. An A13 may well not make them money, but the whole Iphone does.
- scarface74 6y agoAnd Amazon doesn’t make money off chips. It makes money selling services that run on chips. They both sell integrated products. But, we also aren’t talking about all chips. Just server class chips. Energy cost is also a very real cost at the scale of the cloud vendors. If they can decrease the overall cost and the cost/per watt. It’s a win.
- Spooky23 6y agoI doubt it. The A13 and successors are money printing machines. Apple has always been about limiting SKUs to maximize their economies of scale. The original iMac was a great example of this... although they had no market share, they had like 3 SKUs vs HP and Dell who had dozens or hundreds of different PCs. It was the biggest selling model of computer at the time, and they make money on it because of that scale. They do the same thing with the iPhone today. The SE has the same guts as the flagship SKU, which is in turn faster than any competing product. The control of the roadmap and capabilities of the CPUs is a huge competitive advantage that makes a lot of money. They save money on things they don’t control like batteries because the faster CPU uses less power, etc. Everyone else is stuck with whatever garbage Qualcomm is dishing out. Amazon is in a similar place. There remains a lot of on-premise server compute that AWS wants to conquer. You need to think about their actions today in terms of what they mean in 2030.
- scarface74 6y agoJust to add on. Amazon frequently talks about only 5% of Enterprise workloads are on any cloud provider.
- Spooky23 6y agoExactly. I work in the enterprise space, and we are the frog in the slowly boiling water. In 2009, cloud email was unthinkable, in 2012, on-prem email was unthinkable. Most compute workloads are the same, and the sorry state of the legacy hardware companies is testament to that. HPE sold off its field services to Unisys, the Dell conglomerate exists (owing to the collapse in valuation of once mighty EMC), IBM is whatever IBM has become, etc. Oracle essentially doesn’t pay salespeople for selling traditional software. At some point, more enterprise workloads just won’t be feasible anywhere but cloud. The stupid government or a bank will pay a few FTEs to swap parts for $1M/year, but everyone else will have moved to cloud.
- ClumsyPilot 6y agoA national government has a very different risk calculus. Imagine you are, say, Indian government, you have to trust AWS with your data and they won't shut you off if Donald trump goes nuts.
- mappu 6y ago> They save money on things they don’t control like batteries because the faster CPU uses less power, etc. Everyone else is stuck with whatever garbage Qualcomm is dishing out. I don't think the battery/CPU relation you posit is true - the A13 is faster in single-core performance than the Snapdragon 865 (or 855), but consumes more total power to do the same work: https://images.anandtech.com/doci/15207/SPEC2006_S865.png https://images.anandtech.com/doci/15207/SPEC2006_S865.png I think all this tells you is that ARM's big cores chose a power/performance curve point well below the A13. The upcoming Cortex-X1 in next year's 875 will be their first attempt at breaking into that market.
- Spooky23 6y agoI’m not an expert in mobile CPU’s, but I know that those benchmarks are server benchmarks and aren’t designed for a mobile use case. Mobile CPUs usually have low power and high performance modes, and aggressively shed power loads when idle. I’m not sure what benchmark is appropriate, but I wouldn’t draw much from that one.
- uluyol 6y ago> No amount I can imagine can pay off for the tapeout on the latest node for them. All dotcoms taken together make for single digit percentage of wafer output for both Intel, or AMD. Source?