4 ms·
This reads almost as a parody of tech entrepreneurship and the modern age. Steve Jobs is more praiseworthy than da Vinci, because he "shipped" products for the
by keiferski 6y ago
This reads almost as a parody of tech entrepreneurship and the modern age. Steve Jobs is more praiseworthy than da Vinci, because he "shipped" products for the consumer market, as compared to da Vinci, who was more interested in artistic and scientific knowledge for its own sake? Is this legitimately what the author thinks?
The post is also wrong/misinformed on a number of things. Da Vinci did intend to build a number of his plans, but was thwarted by the fact that he lived in conflict-ridden Renaissance Italy. For example, his design for a gigantic bronze horse never became a reality as his patron used the bronze for making cannons.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Leonardo%27s_horse https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Leonardo%27s_horse
- moron4hire 6y agoYeah, it's not like we have Steve Jobs' notebooks to be able to know and compare all of the projects he worked on that never saw the light of day. Apple is notoriously a very secretive company. We often don't find out about canned projects until a decade later. Nobody ships everything they work on. This is a creators' myth that I don't know why keeps getting perpetuated.
- keiferski 6y agoI think the entire argument is absurd. Da Vinci did ship - he created hundreds of artworks and by any measure (other than money) achieved more than Jobs - and I say that as a fan of Steve Jobs.
- moron4hire 6y agoAgreed completely. The proof is in the pudding. Da Vinci has had a massively lasting impact on human culture. 500 years later, we still talk about him.
- asjw 6y agoNot considering the fact that Steve Jobs never thought about and never built something durable. Da Vinci, among many other things, built some of the Milanese navigli which are still there for the people to enjoy almost 6 centuries later I live on one of them (Naviglio della Martesana) and it's beautiful http://www.aboutmilan.com/navigli-of-leonardo-milan.html http://www.aboutmilan.com/navigli-of-leonardo-milan.html
- hn_check 6y agoIt seems like a thought piece meant to elicit consideration, and nothing more. People take these things far too seriously and immediately want to have a position.
- Hokusai 6y ago“ It’s so commonly said that Leonardo was “ahead of his time” but that’s only because he didn’t let the world catch up to his mind. Leonardo never built the future, but we still exaggerate as if he did. Sure, his ideas had significant influence over future inventors, but there’s much more to innovation than sketches on paper.” It seems a provocative piece looking for attention. We are talking about it because it’s extreme position, not for its insights. I hope the author reviews his article and does a second take with a more informed and critical opinion. * https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Science_and_inventions_of_Leonardo_da_Vinci https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Science_and_inventions_of_Leon...
- hn_check 6y agoI'm at -3 above. Good conversation here. A rational, nuanced crowd. LOL. As to the quote, is it wrong? It isn't actually wrong at all. We constantly look to his sketches and say "look at that flying machine" and other contraptions -- inventions sometimes centuries before their time -- but that's retrospective matching. His drawings, though brilliant, did not lead to actual progress.
- cambalache 6y agoI was going to say the same, that this was peak HN to even dare to make such a comparison. Then I saw the author is a kid just graduated from college in engineering and "entrepreneurship". Hopefully there is plenty of time for him to learn and mature.
- JoeAltmaier 6y agoAnd he wasn't a nobleman. Much of his letter writing railed about his being abused and belittled by the aristocracy for being a commoner. Hard to get any traction that way.