4 ms·
How did "social justice warrior" become a slur? Is there anyone who honestly doesn't think Social Justice is a virtue that it is worth fighting for?
by tsimionescu 6y ago
How did "social justice warrior" become a slur? Is there anyone who honestly doesn't think Social Justice is a virtue that it is worth fighting for?
- yulaow 6y agoIt's not the name but how that group of people acts that gives the bad connotation. Even "Fascism" as a etimological concept has not a bad connotation ("suggested strength through unity: a single rod is easily broken, while the bundle is difficult to break"), but as a political group which uses it to identify themselves, it really is extremly bad. Long story short: we cannot just look at the etimology of a word, we need the associated context.
- tsimionescu 6y agoSure, but what are "social justice warriors" doing that is so horrific that it has become an accusation rather than a political label? That is what I am getting at - the way I see it, social justice continues to mean the same thing as it always did: respect for the rights of all minorities, and a genuine desire to see an end to oppression and of the long-standing effects of oppression for all.
- naasking 6y ago> the way I see it, social justice continues to mean the same thing as it always did: respect for the rights of all minorities, and a genuine desire to see an end to oppression and of the long-standing effects of oppression for all. I'm sure that's the way they see their own actions, but not everyone agrees with that framing. I'm guessing the pejorative sense comes from the tactics sometimes employed, and the way social justice goals are sometimes twisted: 1. Destroying individual lives via doxxing and twitter harassment (twitter mobs), rather than tackling powerful people or systems who benefit from or perpetuate systemic bias. 2. A hyper-focus on token gestures with no real effect, like changing technical jargon. 3. Moving the goalposts by redefining basic social justice terms in order to manufacture consent. For instance, sexism and racism. 4. The sometimes violent suppression of speech, and even basic scientific facts, with which they disagree. And more, some of which very much has the flavour of "the ends justify the means", where the ends are a moving target. For a contemporary analogy, the pejorative view might be that SJWs are to real fighters for social justice as rioters and looters are to protestors. Maybe some of the rioters and looters are just so angry at the systemic injustice that they believe that violence is their last resort, but plenty of them are just opportunists.
- tsimionescu 6y agoI agree with your assessment of what is causing some people to dislike those they label SJWs, but I am still deeply bothered by the term used (though I haven't really seen a legitimate example of item 4). We don't call rioters and looters 'BLM warriors' or 'freedom fighters', we call them by the negative characteristics that set them apart. By extension, the term SJW and its association with those who exaggerate and cause harm from the social justice scene seems designed to make social justice seen like a negative, instead of explicitly pointing a finger at doxxers and mobs.
- naasking 6y ago> though I haven't really seen a legitimate example of item 4 A lot of the campus protests had a violent component that wasn't really reported in most media. > We don't call rioters and looters 'BLM warriors' or 'freedom fighters', we call them by the negative characteristics that set them apart. If the rioters called themselves "BLM warriors", people might start using that term pejoratively too.
- tomp 6y agoYes, I do. I think "justice" is worth fighting for, and as soon as "social justice" deviates from "justice" (e.g. positive discrimination, whereas blacks need to score less on SATs than Asians to be admitted) it's in the wrong.
- tsimionescu 6y agoDo you have any views on historic reparations? For example, do you think that at the time general slavery was abolished, it would have been just or not to have taken (some of) the wealth of former slave owners and given it to former slaves? If this was not done at the time, is there a lingering injustice over all of the former slaves? And the same can be asked about the very recent past, when explicit discrimination of black people in schooling, jobs, housing etc. was abolished, would it not have been just to give them back some of the wealth that had been legally denied them for more than a hundred years? Or do you believe that a line can be drawn at any time and everything that happened before can be fully ignored?
- tomp 6y agoI’m ok with reparations to former slaves, but AFAIK none of them are still alive (in the US). Reparations to their descendants (taken from all taxpayers) aren’t IMO any more “just” (or socially beneficial) than reparations from the rich to the poor (poor kids are also disadvantaged at no fault of their own... due to their ancestry). Explicit discrimination should be proven and solved by the usual means (suing, courts, ...). If you mandate a generic white-to-black reparations, you might end up with a situation where a working-class white person (deprivileged) is subsidising Obama’s daughters (extremely privileged). Basically any time you try to project “injustice” or “privilege” on a single dimension (such as race), the result is certainly unjust.
- tsimionescu 6y agoWhat about reparations to people who lived under Jim Crow? Many of those are still alive. And no, I'm not saying you should do white-to-black reparations. But that's not to say it is just to do nothing. Particularly for pre-civil rights laws, the state could use its resources to undo the damage it did itself, and offer direct monetary aid or other advantages to those it wronged for so much time. Doing nothing is not justice, it is explicitly continuing the injustice.
- skocznymroczny 6y agoAs usual, the devil is in the details. I believe in a society that is blind to race, gender, class. This is my view of social justice. But this is in opposite of the SJW ideology, who claim that because of systemic discrimination, the only way towards equality is reverse discrimination.
- tsimionescu 6y agoI asked another commenter as well, but how do you think the hundred years of legal discrimination and two hundred years of slavery before that can be redressed to help bring the former victims up to date with the rest of society? Are any kind of reparations out of the question from your point of view? The same can of course be asked about women, gay people, Irish people, Italians and all other minorities who were historically oppressed in the US - does the day that the most explicit discrimination stop equal day 1, as if the past weren't relevant at all?
- luckylion 6y agoYou cannot have social/collective justice and individual injustice at the same time. People who like individual justice (aka "justice") will generally have an issue with "social justice", yes.
- tsimionescu 6y agoWhere exactly is social justice against individual justice? I for one am both for social justice and for individual justice - I don't believe an injustice should ever be forgiven. At the very least, the vast majority of social justice ideals are perfectly compatible (and in fact require) individual justice as well. Social justice does tend to focus especially on the rights of historically (or currently) discriminated against minorities. Basically, about making it clear that discrimination can never be just. I suspect that you have a major problem with the second aspect of that - that is the obvious observation that discrimination and its effects does not simply stop the moment the legal principle is removed. Justice is not restored simply by releasing a wrongly imprisoned person after 50 years. You must provide reparations for the 50 years of unjust imprisonment, all the lost opportunities. And the same must somehow apply for entire groups of people who have been discriminated against for far longer time.
- luckylion 6y ago> Where exactly is social justice against individual justice? "This person should get the job because of social justice" means "That person should not get the job". You have discriminated against that person because of innate attributes they have no control over. That's obviously unjust. > Social justice does tend to focus especially on the rights of historically (or currently) discriminated against minorities. Yes, but groups are a terrible idea for those kinds of things. A wealthy black Nigerian emigrated to the US in the 70ies and had a son. That son now qualifies as a minority that should get affirmative action, while e.g. some white kid whose ancestors were slaves (indentured servitude is considered a form of slavery) would not. If you only look at group-membership, you are not looking at individuals, and you're not looking for individual justice. > And the same must somehow apply for entire groups of people who have been discriminated against for far longer time. Where do we start? And who are those groups? Are "Africans" such a group? The Barbary Slave Trade had Northern Africans regularly pillage towns in Southern Europe, kidnap Europeans and then sell them as slaves on slave markets throughout the Ottoman Empire. Do I as an European who had (to the best of my knowledge) no kidnapped slave anywhere in my ancestry, now get reparations from some Moroccan person? Or do we just trade claims and nobody gets anything? You'll notice that the wrongly imprisoned person themselves will get money (laughably little, I may add; it's insult to injury, really). Not some random person that accidentally shares their skin color, gender, ethnicity, political or religious convictions. Germany (and especially German companies using slave labor) paying money to Holocaust survivors or their family makes sense to me. Germany paying money to a jew who lived in Canada since 1900, hasn't lost anyone in the Holocaust and hasn't suffered more because of the war than any other Canadian? Less so, I suppose? To someone who isn't ethnically Jewish, lived in Canada since 1900, hasn't lost anyone etc pp, BUT converted to Judaism in 1945? Is he part of the group that should receive group reparations or not? I'm sure you're seeing where I'm going with this: groups aren't easily identifiable, aren't clear-cut, and if you really want justice, you'll probably have to go back a long time. Should Germany say "yeah, sorry about all that Holocaust business, but here's an IOU we have from the Romans for their invasion 2000 years ago, please collect your reparations from them"? You're getting nowhere with group justice. Focus on individual justice, you can make a much better case for it, and you're not creating new victims every time you try to right a wrong.
- finnthehuman 6y agoIt derives from "keyboard warrior", a term we used on the Internet back in the days when goals you like could be separated from presentation you don't.
- tsimionescu 6y agoThe term is often used about activists, public speakers, opinion leaders etc, so I don't believe your etymology is correct. It is not a term coming from internet circles. Also, keyboard warrior has an explicit reference to being ineffective in your convictions (fighting with your keyboard, a useless weapon). Social justice warrior, if it were etymological related, would have to mean someone who is fighting with the use of social justice. Instead, it refers to someone who fights for social justice, which is not meant as ineffective, but as harmful.