4 ms·
Replacing master/slave with leader/follower makes perfect sense, given historical context. Is blacklist/whitelist inherently racist, or does it have racist ori
by sneak 6y ago
Replacing master/slave with leader/follower makes perfect sense, given historical context.
Is blacklist/whitelist inherently racist, or does it have racist origins? Try as I might I don’t see inherent bias in it.
- anonfunction 6y agoThe connotation is that white is good and black is bad.
- tomp 6y agoWouldn't it make more sense then to change the name of the race? "Blacks" -> "browns" or something... (and it would also be more physically accurate... same with "whites" -> "yellows" or "roses")
- rurban 6y agoYes, but I don't see the correlation to any race. black is bad everywhere, probably because of its physical properties. ditto for white. Those who wish to see a racial relation are just racists, and racists should not be fed.
- j-pb 6y agoWhich has nothing to do with race, and is heavily rooted in "light" vs. "shadow" mythology. In India it's the other way around, Asia has Ying and Yang. Changing these words is a feel good thing, that does nothing to address our internal biases, prejudices, and racism. It wastes time that could be spend on writing your senator, politician, or being active in a political party. It's a zero effort, zero stakes thing, that makes privileged people feel personal accomplishment, while allowing them to relax into complacency. "I make a million a year, and work for a company that makes money off of algorithmically radicalising people into right wing conspiracy theories, but I don't use the word white- and black-list anymore, because it reminds me of race. I did my part!"
- leg100 6y agoThat's a connotation. Another one is that black you cannot see, white you can. Which does have some grounding in physics. And no, absolutely nothing to do with race.
- simo7 6y agoOf course...some people seem to have an obsession for race, they connotate everything with it.
- mudita 6y agoTo me it seems that this connotation is very deeply embedded in Western culture (but not only Western culture, compare for example yin and yang) and doesn't actually have much to do with race, and more with day and night, light and darkness and the fact that humans are not a nocturnal species and darkness can be dangerous to us. According to https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Black-and-white_dualism https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Black-and-white_dualism this is traceable to the Ancient Near East and listed in the Pythagorean Table of Opposites for example, so it goes much further back than the Atlantic slave trade. I do not think that it would be possible to rip this metaphor out of our thinking. By the way, a really great linguistic book about how much of our thinking is in systematic metaphors in general, is "Metaphors We Live By", by George Lakoff and Mark Johnson.
- dvfjsdhgfv 6y ago> I do not think that it would be possible to rip this metaphor out of our thinking. But this is exactly what certain people are trying to do. And it's not a fringe group anymore, this is starting to touch different aspects of our life that have no any real relation to racism or skin color. If "black" in "blacklist" is offending you today, tomorrow you will be offended by Master's degree.
- lol139189 6y ago(Almost) No-one is really offended by any of this. This is a purity test - it's about easily being able to identify people who still have any semblance of personal agency so they can be isolated and ostracized.
- tsimionescu 6y agoYes, but it is worth noting that this did not originally refer to skin color, but more to the association in our culture of black with death.
- zeeZ 6y agoWe should remove short and long because you can use those words to describe people's height or other features. You can argue for the replacement of black- and whitelisting with allow- and Blocklisting because it removes the intermediary step of having to know that the color white/light is usually seen on our culture as something representing good, while black/darkness is seen as bad. Different cultures may see those differently, such as white also representing death and mourning in Japan, which may cause confusion. But this change likely came from current events and has nothing to do with the above other than someone on Twitter thinking "blacklisting -> black people -> that's racist" and getting upset about it. ️