7 ms·
I still don't really get the point of 5G. It requires so many towers that you're basically building a wired network, but then it requires billions of dollars wo
by AnthonyMouse 6y ago
I still don't really get the point of 5G. It requires so many towers that you're basically building a wired network, but then it requires billions of dollars worth of wireless spectrum in order to get from what amounts to the street in front of your house to inside, even though there are already phone lines and coax going there that could be used. Even for wireless devices, that would get you close enough to use unlicensed spectrum (WiFi) and save billions of dollars worth of licensed spectrum.
The main benefit of cellular is when you're away from WiFi. But unless you're constantly traveling to places without WiFi, you get that from a $20/month plan and the existing cellular network.
- sudosysgen 6y agoThe benefit is mostly realized in places where you can expect to see the cost savings trickle down and have very high amounts of data for 25$/month. Which, to be honest, is not North America right now, but that certainly will become a reality in some places.
- AnthonyMouse 6y agoHow do you charge $25/month when you have to maintain a huge fiber network to the 5G towers on every street?
- cinquemb 6y agoLarge cheap loans from the federal reserve only they have access to and you don't. Also helps when FRBNY in conjunction with the Tresury dept via state street and blackrock is buying their HY bonds (TMUS US87264AAT25 [Ba3], S US85207UAK16 [B1], CTL US156700BC99 [Ba3], LVLT US527298BF96 [Ba3], VOD US92857WBQ24 [Ba1] for just a few examples, all trading way over par) on you, the taxpayers behalf, on leverage, in the secondary market and thus helping to lower their ongoing borrowing costs.
- djannzjkzxn 6y agoConsumers can get a mortgage with 3% interest rate.
- cinquemb 6y agoYeah, with the house as collateral (assuming one even wants a house) and a knock on their credit rating if they miss a payment they have to pay for 10-30 years… comparable to multi billion $ unsecured debt these folks can get at similar rates at current yields to maturity values for 5-10 years… lol
- scarface74 6y agoIf you call the bank in advance - especially post Covid - a lot of times they won’t ding your credit for a missed payment. Besides, the two biggest things most people need credit for are home loans and car loans. You can get a car with less than perfect credit or even get a beater for cash.
- cinquemb 6y agoAnd yet, somehow, being able to get two collateralized loans for peanuts in value are comparable to being able to get many uncollateralized ones rolled over for years (yes they were junk before covid) for billions… No gross mis-allocation of resources or moral hazards as far as one eyes can see… surely the companies will use these funds much better this time for capex… lol
- djannzjkzxn 6y agoTotal US mortgage debt and corporate debt are around the same size - roughly $15 trillion each. Mortgage and corporate bondholders have both seen principal losses in recent history. Fed support is pushing down both types of rates, and it’s not obvious to me that one is somehow unfairly pushed down more than the other.
- est31 6y agoYou only need 5G towers on every street in places where there are many customers. In other places you can place towers less densely. In the places with many customers, you also see lots of revenue.
- AnthonyMouse 6y agoAllow me to rephrase. The number of customers per tower is worse than with 4G, so how is it going to cost less?
- est31 6y agoHmm yeah that's a bit confusing. I think there are two effects here at play: * The higher data density of 5G per spectrum allows you to just upgrade towers instead of having to place more dense towers with 4G. This is the "5G is cheaper" point as it allows you to avoid having to build more towers. * Due to the increase in data demand in some few places places, you'll have to place 5G towers very densely to meet it, more densely than in the age of 4G. Not because of the technology just because it's now a different era where demand has increased even more.
- AnthonyMouse 6y ago> The higher data density of 5G per spectrum allows you to just upgrade towers instead of having to place more dense towers with 4G. This is the "5G is cheaper" point as it allows you to avoid having to build more towers. So this seems like only a theoretical possibility since in practice they'll just have faster towers instead of fewer of them. > Due to the increase in data demand in some few places places, you'll have to place 5G towers very densely to meet it, more densely than in the age of 4G. Not because of the technology just because it's now a different era where demand has increased even more. For millimeter wave it is because of the technology. Those frequencies don't penetrate as well so regardless of how many users there are or how much bandwidth they're using, the towers have to be closer to the devices which means you need more of them.
- 6y ago
- harpratap 6y agoThe answer is you don't have to maintain the network on your own, your users will help you do it for you. One example is this - https://network.mobile.rakuten.co.jp/area/rakuten-casa/ https://network.mobile.rakuten.co.jp/area/rakuten-casa/ it's a femtocell that is given away for nearly no cost to users and not only boosts network in your own house but also for people living near you.
- croutonwagon 6y agoBut then you are reliant on a different carrier and network for yours to work. Most users home routers are garbage for latency and loss sensitive applications, of which voice would qualify. Not to mention the security implications from both angles. As an end user do you want random cell phone traffic egressing through your network. And that easily opens up the network to cell site spoofing moreso than they already are. A big reason LTE, GSM, evdo etc were successfull was because the full stack, from the backbone to endpoint/user was managed by the carrier. Offloading that to home users who actively put routers in between interference sources like windows, fridges, washers/dryers and then tey and extend their signal with repeaters is a questionable goal at best.
- harpratap 6y ago> But then you are reliant on a different carrier and network for yours to work. Why? You could easily enforce a policy that only who use your fiber network at home qualify for these femtocells. Considering that majority of backbone fiber is an oligopoly already, this wouldn't be an issue. > Most users home routers are garbage for latency and loss sensitive applications, of which voice would qualify. Do you have any source on this claim? IP network has become just as fast and resiliant as the pure teleco network (reason why 5G is based on IP in the first place). IP calls from Facetime, Google Duo, Skype, Zoom, Whatsapp and others work just as good as regular calls if you have decent coverage. And you can easily implement QoS for calls through your own network, which is what the old 3G/4G tech was already doing. > And that easily opens up the network to cell site spoofing moreso than they already are How common is WiFi spoofing in your experience? > A big reason LTE, GSM, evdo etc were successfull was because the full stack, from the backbone to endpoint/user was managed by the carrier The reason they had to do that was because IP stack wasn't good enough 2 decades or even a decade ago. Unless you are in a 3rd world country, IP network is just as good as 3G/4G stack today. > Offloading that to home users who actively put routers in between interference sources like windows, fridges, washers/dryers and then tey and extend their signal with repeaters is a questionable goal at best. Okay, you might want to revisit that thought couple of years from now :)
- o-__-o 6y ago5G uses UWB Edit: apparently 5G does not use UWB
- phonon 6y ago5G does not use UWB.
- mintyc 6y agoHmmm, It will. If 800MHz bandwidth is considered UWB Think video delivery kiosk - I'd like to rent a movie please or I'd like today's daily news videos/VR. Downloaded in 3 secs from a vending machine?
- phonon 6y agoUWB is very low power, with a large number of pulses of very low amplitude typically below the noise level, over a large bandwidth (minimum 500 MHz). It's not just the bandwidth. UWB has a peak power density limit of −41.3 dBm/MHz. 5G is 55 dBm. Note the many, many, many orders of magnitude difference...
- noble_pleb 6y agoMore interesting than 5G is the Amazon's ambitious LEO Project[1], a plan to launch several lower orbit satellites (LEOs) so that plebs can have internet access directly. Will be very useful in dictatorial regimes who censor/control internet in their countries. This will probably render 5G useless. [1] https://www.theverge.com/2019/4/4/18295310/amazon-project-kuiper-satellite-internet-low-earth-orbit-facebook-spacex-starlink https://www.theverge.com/2019/4/4/18295310/amazon-project-ku...
- est31 6y ago5G won't become useless by satellite internet. Satellite internet has upper limits on bandwidth per area.
- dehrmann 6y agoWhere 5G should excel (and LEO fail) is large gatherings like concerts and sporting events.
- est31 6y agoCommunication with satellites requires end devices to have huge antennas. They can maybe be put into cars, but definitely not into phones. Satellites are useful, for those 5% of users that live in so remote areas that you'd have to do a ton of digging to give them fiber, but this myth that they will render 5G or LTE useless is repeated often but wrong.
- scarface74 6y agoSatellite phones for remote areas have been a thing for decades specialized uses.
- mintyc 6y ago5G access (non mobile) deliberately supports 'non-terrestrial networks' of which satellites, floating balloons, repeaters on planes etc are part. Seamless access/mobility and accessibility to maritime, airline, remote satellite phones etc is one of the ways 5G is hoping to sell 'access anywhere' and diversify from just mobile. Most NTN access is via a terrestrial satellite basestation acting as a gateway into the mobile networks. I think one day the communication 'transport' will be a worldwide mesh and operator profitability will be solely about business services on top of that. Already seeing that to some extent with multiple operators sharing towers, radio front haul and spectrum. At the moment its early days of course.
- gsich 6y agoYou can also deploy 5G in the low frequency bands. Nobody talks about that though, as speed is only slightly faster than LTE.
- mintyc 6y agoAgreed. The point is that as more services migrate to higher bands or more spectrum is made available (TV spectrum partially reallocated, 3G is sunset), there is more capacity available for rural locations that need that lower band. Lots of work on alternatives to fibre for those last few miles e.g. dedicated wireless links to local distribution nodes in villages.
- anticensor 6y ago5G has many modes. What you mentioned only applies to over 6GHz.
- jotm 6y agoWiFi is rather terrible, and I believe 5G aims to compete with it along with other standards. I have a 90 sqm two storey house with a detached garage, workshop and quite a bit of land around it and I need 6 WiFi routers to get a signal everywhere, and even then it's spotty and slow. Sometimes makes me wish I just had a data SIM on all devices and be done with it. Open source 4g/5G stuff that was posted a while ago looks really nice, but apparently it would be illegal to operate :/
- contravariant 6y agoMaybe I misunderstood but as far as I know the high frequency mode of 5G would be worse than Wifi at providing coverage.
- StuffMaster 6y ago"Wifi and wires are cheaper" is your argument. >The main benefit of cellular is when you're away from WiFi. For you maybe. The billions you mention are a result of government auctioning, it doesn't mean anything to users besides added cost.
- karl-j 6y ago5G is not mainly for consumers like you and me. We are not willing to pay significantly more for the faster speeds, most people are plenty happy with 4G. The big difference with the 4G to 5G transition compared to the previous transitions is not speed, but flexibility. 5G aims to allow for completely new applications that were not possible before, and hoping that's where the money will come from. Ultra-reliable and low latency, and massive machine type communications are two new areas 5G is pushing into. The first will allow applications like self driving cars, remote control with immediate feedback, and combined with the increased speeds, augmented and virtual reality. The second area is for the smart city/home type of applications. This is all from my digital communications professor with ties to Ericsson, but on a personal note I'd be hype to explore distant places in real time by wearing a vr headset and controlling a drone with a 360° camera and <10ms latency. You could be anywhere in the world and actually interact with the environment with just a 5G enabled headset and a 5G-drone renting app. Racing through an abandoned mall! Drone laser tag in a redwood forest!
- gizmo 6y agoWhy would 5G be a big deal for self-driving cars? Any self-driving that requires ubiquitous low-latency communication is hopeless. Self-driving is a vision problem, and it has to work in a messy world.
- nujabe 6y agoI think the main purpose is for car-to-car communication, latency could be very critical in some situations.
- vkoskiv 6y agoDo human drivers have instant car-to-car communication? No. So why should a self-driving car have it? Self-driving cars will never happen if the fundamental assumption is that every single vehicle on the road is able to actively communicate like that.
- vkoskiv 6y ago