4 ms·
Nice. Users have been screaming about how much changed between 2.79 and 2.81. They should have called it Blender 3. The Blender 2.8x experience has too much of
by Animats 6y ago
Nice. Users have been screaming about how much changed between 2.79 and 2.81. They should have called it Blender 3.
The Blender 2.8x experience has too much of "where did they put ???". Remember, this is a 3D animation program capable of film quality, with UI complexity far beyond most applications. I spent 15 minutes yesterday looking for the "align" tool, which isn't where the "current" documentation says it is. That's a daily experience coming from 2.79.
Actually, the 2.8x series is pretty good. But it obsoleted most of the published Blender books, of which there are many, and most of the user base.
So a stable version, to give users some relief and allow the documentation to catch up, is a big win.
- punnerud 6y agoWould love to see a feature where we can search for a button/setting, and Blender would highlight it. Just like search in DataGrip (JetBrain) for Mac.
- flafla2 6y agoThis actually exists (press F3, with default keybindings)
- akavel 6y agoI understand old users and experts may be annoyed at the fact things were moved, breaking their muscle memory (though I think this is at least partially mitigated by "classic" shortcuts map?). However please note, that for people who were always afraid and intimidated by Blender before, the new interface is an absolute game-changer. I finally feel I have some fighting chance to maybe try and slowly learn at least some of its basics, whereas before I felt completely alienated and frustrated even in the smallest GUI elements. More than that, I finally felt I can recommed trying to learn Blender to my close artist friend, who's not very much into computers, and whom I'd never dare to try and recommend the old version. Even with the new version I saw that for them it feels fairly hard and tricky to use, but now also definitively kinda somewhat familiar and maybe usable (the jury is still out, but I felt super happy when they since asked me "hey, so what was the name of this program you showed me?"). In my opinion, this is a seminal example of how to push a typically "nerdy" open-source project's GUI into a user-friendly one, bordering even on intuitive. I am amazed somebody, or the whole community (I don't know the story), managed to pull this out so well. And before Blender did it, I seriously didn't think an open-source project could manage to pull it out. If you take this into perspective, I think the changes to expert users' workflow, however painful, may actually soon prove to be relatively forgettable. If I am mot mistaken, I think all the old functions are still there; so after a period of frustrations of relearning the menus, I believe you're be no less productive than before. Whereas droves of people will suddenly be able to discover Blender and feel welcome into its interface, and empowered by the possibilities it opens before them. I sincerely bow with respect and amazement before the authors of this change.
- thosakwe 6y agoI never got the hang of Blender in my previous attempts, but I started again with 2.8 in 2019, and the interface made a world of difference. In the past 8 months, I've gone from literally zero knowledge of box modeling to being able to create assets for indie games. I haven't seen any issues with the manual. Actually, combined with the official YouTube tutorials, I've found it extremely easy to find the answers to my questions.
- greggman3 6y agoIt's still frustrating how different it is from all other software. I know blender people are used to it but there are UI conventions. They work on all other programs. they fail on blender for "reasons". One simple example. Click to select, press the Delete key to delete. Works pretty much everywhere. But no, Blender wants you to press X Another is the way you move and or create window panes. Pretty much all other apps you just drag the title/tab/corner and if you to close there's (a) a close [x] icon, (b) no icon but drag the tab out to a separate window and one will appear (c) right click the tab for a context menu. None of these work in blender so it's off to search for a tutorial on how to close a window. Another is using a non-standard file dialog which breaks all kinds of conventions. Sure they wanted more options I guess (though OS ones offer a place to add options). Or they wanted one UI across platforms, except of course people on each platform use used to that platform's conventions... etc... Still it's amazing software
- TD-Linux 6y ago>One simple example. Click to select, press the Delete key to delete. Works pretty much everywhere. But no, Blender wants you to press X Both of these examples work as you'd expect in Blender 2.8+. You may want to try out a new version of the software.
- throwaway936482 6y agoFile dialogue is also much more standard since 2.82. delete has worked as expected for many many (many) (since at least 2010) years
- robomartin 6y agoMy kids are learning Blender on Udemy. One of them got started before the other and ended-up with v2.81. The other ended-up starting later and installed 2.83. He couldn't find buttons and certain functions didn't work as per the course he was following. He ended-up installing 2.81 to be able to get on with it. I didn't dig into it so I don't know what the issues were. I seem to remember that object scaling wasn't behaving as it used to. We had two laptops side-by-side with 2.81 vs. 2.83 and they didn't do the same things. Not sure if this is normal with Blender minor version changes. Like I said, going back to 2.81 dealt with the issue, so no big deal.
- panzerklein 6y agoBlender's versioning is a bit confusing. Change in the second number is not a minor release, but a proper major. They acknowledged it and gonna adopt more conventional versioning scheme for the upcoming 3.x [1] 3d software is a complex thing, many things could be unexpected for inexperienced users. I would suggest asking a question on Blender Stack Exchange [2] instead of downgrading. [1] https://code.blender.org/2020/02/release-planning-2020-2025/ https://code.blender.org/2020/02/release-planning-2020-2025/ [2] https://blender.stackexchange.com/ https://blender.stackexchange.com/
- ashtonkem 6y agoHaving tried to learn Blender back in the 2.7 days, and having learned it this week on 2.82, the improvement in UX is almost impossible to overstate.