3 ms·
USB-C on a USB device(UFP-only) system is wonderful. It's quite simple--two resistors--that gets you 5V at 900mA and USB 2.0 High Speed (480Mbps). Or, if you'
by bsder 6y ago
USB-C on a USB device(UFP-only) system is wonderful. It's quite simple--two resistors--that gets you 5V at 900mA and USB 2.0 High Speed (480Mbps). Or, if you'd like 5V at 1.5A or 3.0A--you generally need a very small and simple chip to handle the CC monitoring.
That's it.
The problem starts occurring when people want to do a zillion things on the port--charge their phone, charge a device, communicate with a device, serve as a device, transfer at Gbps rates, etc.
Remember OTG--oh, yeah, nobody does because it worked like crap. USB-C actually did what OTG was trying to do.
And, the problem mostly isn't USB-C, it's manufacturers:
> All the new port has done is push some components out of the laptop and onto the other end of the cable.
Exactly. And it's the reason I STILL can't get a useful USB-C hub.
Samsung could have avoided the problem with PPS with <$10 of components, instead they pushed those out. Samsung doesn't even supply the "good" charger by default with their device. Don't complain about USB-C because the manufacturers are doing weird things with it to cheapen their bill of materials.
> USB-C audio is basically dead as Bluetooth takes over.
Until latency matters. Then suddenly Bluetooth is a pile of suck. If you're watching a video (the device can delay the video to match latency) or listening to music, fine.
If you're watching something live or you are filming something live, then the latency is maddening.
And that doesn't even start to deal with people who want some sort of audio app. There is a reason why "rhythm" games simply don't exist on mobile.
- fragmede 6y agoOTG worked well enough, when I was able to get the right cable (or device - there are some USB flash drives with micro-USB ports that lean on USB OTG to work). USB-C docking stations are finally hitting the market. They're pricey, but there are some with multiple USB-A ports, USB-C ports (including data), HDMI, DisplayPort, Gig Ethernet, and 3.5mm audio jacks. There are also finally Thunderbolt docks which have thunderbolt ports that connect via USB-C. (They are even more expensive though.) > There is a reason why "rhythm" games simply don't exist on mobile. Rhythm games' heyday aka DDR and Guitar Hero may have passed, but there are plenty. https://my-best.net/16982 https://my-best.net/16982 There are tons of mobile audio apps as well. Korg has a bunch of them. https://www.korg.com/us/products/software/ https://www.korg.com/us/products/software/
- bsder 6y ago> Korg has a bunch of them. https://www.korg.com/us/products/software/ https://www.korg.com/us/products/software/ No Android and no bluetooth for exactly the reason I mention. Korg actually has a DAW-lite for the Nintendo Switch but not Android precisely because you can manage audio latency on the Switch but can't on Android.
- cardiffspaceman 6y ago> the problem mostly isn't USB-C, it's manufacturers So can't we complain about the joint results of the manufacturers AND the USB consortium and thus label USB a failure (or a success if someday they overcome this)? I think this is turning into a true-Scotsman discussion.
- bsder 6y agoAs for the standard, you say this like there is some pure, platonic communication standard that is somehow magically better somewhere out there. Everything that exists in USB-C is there because someone really wanted it there. Would you prefer to have 14 incompatible charging standards? That's what you had before USB PD. Now, my 45W USB-C GaN charger is the size of a deck of cards and can pretty much fast charge anything I plug it into (laptop, phone, tablet, etc.). And you can complain about video, but I've actually had HDMI cables that don't work because I can't tell whether they support HDMI 1.2/1.4/2.0/2.0b/2.1, ethernet, 50Hz, etc.--so it's not like HDMI is magically better. And for years I've been unable to figure out why full-size Displayport cables all seem to magically work while 90% of mini-Displayport cables fail horribly. And manufacturers, and not the USB Consortium, are absolutely to blame for the fact that they used to include 4 USB A ports but somehow can only cough up 2 USB-C ports on even the most expensive laptops. And somehow they screw even that up such that one port overheats your computer.