5 ms·
What exactly is the “fascism” that we’re worried about spreading?
by rayiner 6y ago
What exactly is the “fascism” that we’re worried about spreading?
- supercanuck 6y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fascism https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fascism
- rayiner 6y ago> Fascists believe that liberal democracy is obsolete and regard the complete mobilization of society under a totalitarian one-party state as necessary to prepare a nation for armed conflict and to respond effectively to economic difficulties. So that means fighting against the Green New Deal and people like AOC?
- kennywinker 6y agoYou can fight against a green new deal without being fascist. But if you fight it by doing or allowing people to do things that undermine democracy, like say... withholding aid funds to coerce other nations to do things that hurt your political opponents... yeah, that leans towards fascism.
- rayiner 6y agoNo, I’m saying that, according to your link, fascism attacks liberal democracy and advocates for the “complete mobilization of society” to a single end. That’s exactly what the Green New Deal is.
- supercanuck 6y agoThe link is to wikipedia, if you think it is wrong, you could edit and submit that for review. You also add your insight on the Green New Deal being an example of facism.
- kennywinker 6y agoNot my link. But it feels like you’re intentionally misunderstanding what fascism is to try to make a point. Yes, the green new deal is a mobilization of society to a single end. Is anyone attempting to use “dictatorial power, forcible suppression of opposition” to do it? No. Nobody is. Tigers are animals with stripes. Zebras are animals with stripes. A zebra is not a tiger. The green new deal could be part of a fascist movement, but it’s not.
- tptacek 6y agoObviously it can't be the case that any form of mobilization is equivalent to fascism. Societies mobilize all the time. According to Payne, fascism has a consistent goal of creating a new nationalist authoritarian state, with not simply a mobilization but a militarization of the populace --- a "mass party militia". There's a kind of "horseshoe theory of politics" thing that happens with observations about Soviet communism and Italian fascism. Both systems are bad, and they share specific bad characteristics. But they are not the same; in fact, they're antithetical to each other. I think the Green New Deal is poorly specified and ill-advised, but it is not Soviet communism and certainly not fascistic, and AOC is not a "charismatic authoritarian" in the fascist sense. It was a silly comparison to have made.
- tryptophan 6y agoPeople voting for trump.
- Avicebron 6y agoAnd not people advocating mass censorship on communication platforms? Please, you're biases are showing and it's embarrassing.
- ryeights 6y agoI think you missed the irony in GP's comment
- kennywinker 6y agoYou can't have it both ways. Either facebook/twitter/instagram are common-carrier public squares, or they are private corporations. If they are private corps, they can block whatever they want. If they are common carriers, they can't censor people, but they will also have to open up their platforms to competition and submit to more government oversight to allow for fair and equal access.
- Avicebron 6y agoI see no issue with the second option. Do you have an argument against that?
- kennywinker 6y agoNope. I'm for it. But you can't get upset about social media "censorship" without calling for these companies to be treated as common carrier / public squares and I see a lot of the former and not a lot of the latter. I suspect because gov. regulation of enterprise is traditionally opposed by the same right wing that is currently upset about social media censorship.
- kennywinker 6y agoHave you not been paying attention this past three years? Rampant nationalism, children in cages (still happening), police brutality and murder without repercussions, teargassing and beating peaceful protesters, the attorney general asserting that the president cannot break the law. I could go on, but if those don't make you worried about the threat of fascism, I'm not sure what would...
- collegecamp293 6y ago"Children in cages" happened during the Obama administration. No uproar then?
- wetmore 6y agoYou're really missing the forest for the trees there.
- kennywinker 6y agoOh, sorry, so the nation has been listing towards fascism for decades? That is not a refuting of any of my points. Bush started the use of drones in war, but Obama bears the blame for them in my opinion, because he could have backed away from it but instead he doubled down. I would say the same for the treatment of refugees at the border. Obama built the cages, but Trump uses them with a sickening joy and enthusiasm.
- SamReidHughes 6y agoYou seem to be misremembering. It was separating children from their family, not caging them, that people were complaining about last election season, because of perfectly ordinary border enforcement arresting illegal aliens. The exception was some misaligned activists that accidentally posted Obama-era photos of "caged" children (behind a fence) a couple weeks early, which happened before some lawsuit forced the feds to release the children instead of housing them with their parents.
- 6y ago