3 ms·
I'm not seeing anything dismissive in OP's remark. Opposing police brutality is not the same thing as being anti-police.
by zozbot234 6y ago
I'm not seeing anything dismissive in OP's remark. Opposing police brutality is not the same thing as being anti-police.
- vore 6y ago"Very good, adult take. Calm, balanced" is pretty dismissive of people being rightfully angry.
- zozbot234 6y agoSo we shouldn't act as adults or be calm and balanced? People can rightfully oppose something in a reasonable way.
- danaris 6y agoThat appears to be a strawman argument. Being calm and balanced is good, yes. But that's not the same thing as saying that anger is not justified, and that it automatically means that the angry person should be dismissed and their anger treated as a symptom of an immature or unbalanced person. Vore was simply noting that, given the current circumstances, m0zg's original comment could very easily be read as saying, "Ah, good, here's someone who's actually worth listening to. Not like those angry, irrational protesters."
- m0zg 6y agoThe protesters aren't really suggesting anything realistic though. Or if they are, their message is completely drowned out. I feel like society is united around the murder of George Floyd. Now is the time to figure out solutions. Whoever is instigating the riots, however, is driving a wedge into that unity. In the atmosphere of widespread, severe unrest, most people would _easily_ prefer safety over justice. It's been shown again and again. Whoever is driving this wedge knows exactly what they're doing.
- yongjik 6y agoWell, many footages show police using excessive force on peaceful protestors: rubber bullets, pepper sprays, shoving people to ground. As you said, I have a feeling that these officers know exactly what they're doing.
- danaris 6y agoIn several places that I've seen, there have been specific lists of demands that the protesters have given. In general, they center around bringing to justice those officers who have participated in brutality, and effectively reforming the police in their municipalities so that these situations cannot arise again. Frankly, wherever the police are instigating greater violence, they are making more certain that the protests will go on longer and get more publicity than in places where they're being allowed to be peaceful.
- vore 6y agoI literally never said that. I said to not dismiss the angry people. Of course people can talk about it calmly, but putting it on a pedestal as "Very good, adult take" is absolutely patronizing to those affected.
- dredmorbius 6y agoIn context with earlier comments, it's a credible interpretation: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23412122 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23412122
- m0zg 6y agoYes, I am pro-police, and anti-looting. That categorically doesn't mean what you think it means though. I support racial justice. I support police reform, demilitarization, and pushing back against police unions. I think unjustified police brutality, like in the case of George Floyd, should be prosecuted, and it undermines the respect many people have for the police profession. This respect is a _requirement_ for the police to be effective. I also think Chauvin should have been fired in disgrace years ago. My suggestion was in regards to the rather extreme and unjustified comments the public officials were making (and continue to make) towards the police. I hope it is obvious to everyone that without police NYC will be utterly fucked within 24 hours. I stand by those suggestions. If push comes to shove they should go on strike. The vast majority of them are good men and women, and they deserve to be respected. In other words, I'm not 15 years old, I see nuance, and I want some real, lasting solutions to these issues. Sue me.