3 ms·
> I've never had my phone stolen, and I don't know anybody who has even just lost their phone more than once. Errr, to be clear, the reason that phones don’t g
by derefr 6y ago
> I've never had my phone stolen, and I don't know anybody who has even just lost their phone more than once.
Errr, to be clear, the reason that phones don’t get stolen is that there are anti-theft measures in place.
People steal similar types of item (e.g. car stereos, game consoles, Blu-ray players) all the time. There’s no reason other than anti-theft measures that phones as a type of item would be stolen any less than these other categories. (They’d actually be stolen far more, since they’re small/easy to slip into one’s clothes/not a weird thing to be carrying around; and are often found just left on tables at cafes or hanging out of people’s back pockets. They’re like cash, basically.)
It’s the same reason that people steal bicycles more often than they steal cars. Bicycles, despite being worth much less, are just much easier to steal.
> The majority of the world is honest.
Do you live in a city? I’ve had my bicycle stolen five times now. I’ve also been mugged twice. I’ve never had my phone stolen, though—because it’s worthless to the sort of dumb criminals who steal things just to hawk them on the street, rather than to fence them.
It doesn’t require a large fraction of the world to be dishonest, to result in most people in the world having crimes committed against them. A thief will steal from far more than one person in their thieving career. Especially in regimes where the computed ROI for going after certain types of thief (e.g. homeless, drug-addicted thieves) is negative (i.e. their prison housing costs society more than their thieving does, apparently), and so they’re never held for more than a day or two.
- sudosysgen 6y agoTrust me, the #1 reason why phones don't get stolen is because they are physically difficult to steal. If a well-connected thief steals your phone (and there are a lot of well-connected thieves), they will not have much of an issue getting them sold. Then the phone will either be parted out or flashed out of any anti-theft, depending on market demand.
- derefr 6y agoThere are two types of thieves: thieves that operate as part of a professional thieving ring; and thieves that operate alone, intending to directly hawk/pawn/trade/use what they’ve stolen. Most thefts are committed by thieves who operate alone. (This is verifiable at least for my own country; I asked a crime-statistics analyst friend of mine.) Thus, most deterrence is focused on deterring the thieves who act alone. This is the same reason that “security locks” aren’t actually proof against professional thieves. They’re not meant to deter thieving rings; they’re just meant to deter the thieves who are acting alone. Such thieves might have watched a tutorial or two on YouTube on lock-picking, and they might have picked up a lock-picking set from AliExpress; but they don’t have (and aren’t willing/able to invest in) the sort of lock-picking skills/tools that professionals have (e.g. slide-hammers, impact drivers, etc.) so an average security lock will be enough to stymie them. Same with clubs on cars: no proof against professional thieving rings, but good enough to make a thief acting alone look elsewhere. Just like there is a qualitative difference in how people treat things that are “free” vs. “$0.01”, there is a qualitative difference in theft rates between “no security” and “trivial security.” Most property crimes are spur-of-the-moment, committed by people who didn’t come prepared to steal something, but just see an opportunity to take something and feel the need to have it. Put a trivial barrier in the way of taking things, and those spur-of-the-moment crimes committed by “amateur thieves” go away.
- dylz 6y agoFrom what I've seen, the former also seems to heavily spam Craigslist et al "buying locked phones and for parts phones" and "won't ask where you got them, imei reported lost stolen ok" and the latter quite commonly sells it to them for quick, below market, cash.
- sudosysgen 6y agoSure. But in my experience, all it takes is for you to know a guy that knows a guy and it's done. The type of people in the socio-economic situation that makes it so that they would steal phones often leads them to have that kind of contact. In any case, maybe that is not so much the case in the US. But this certainly is the case in Europe; a very, very large percentage of stolen phones are sent to facilities that will part them out or unlock them. It also is true that someone selling a locked phone on Kijiji is likely to end up selling it to someone who has the skill or who knows someone that can unlock it.
- derefr 6y ago> a very, very large percentage of stolen phones are sent to facilities that will part them out or unlock them. But again, that's post-hoc statistics. You're looking at the world that already has the trivial disincentive against amateur thieving. So of course you'll see most stolen phones being stolen by professionals—the amateur thieves are already not bothering, so if a phone is being stolen at this point, it's being stolen by a professional thief! In a world without that disincentive, the statistics would skew very differently. I again compare to the market for stolen bicycles. Yes, there are professional thieves with "bicycle chop shops" et al. But there are also crackheads carrying around bolt-cutters who just want to take a bike they walk by, ride it back to the ghetto, and then sell it for $20 to a street passerby to buy their next fix. Most cities have a large bike-theft problem, and it's mostly from this kind of thief, not from professional thieves. Any "security bike lock"—i.e. any bike lock you can't just snip through with bolt cutters—stops this kind of thief. Look at New York City, for example. There are two types of bikes in NYC: those with security locks, and those that get stolen the instant they're left alone for ten minutes. The security lock wouldn't deter a professional thief—but a professional thief prioritizes, stealing fancy bikes from e.g. university sports department bike parkades, and won't bother with your average commuter bike. The crackhead does not prioritize. They just want $20, and your bike is probably worth $20.
- joecool1029 6y agoStolen phones used to be worth a lot more before Apple threw iCloud locks on and the IMEI blacklists became a thing. Now a stolen phone is mostly only valuable for parts if it isn't fenced quickly, so there's really not the same incentive there used to be. The only thing IMEI blacklisting has succeeded in doing is making it a bitch to buy phones on the used market. At any time the seller could do insurance fraud and claim the phone is stolen and now that phone is (domestically) a tablet at best and the purchaser is left with no recourse. At least with a vendor system like iCloud, there's a fast way to make sure the phone's signed out when you do a purchase on Craiglist or other third party site. At some point we're going to be looking at titling phones (I'm amazed Apple hasn't done so yet) if we ever want to see a used phone market without insurance requirements happen again.
- mindslight 6y agoTitles could actually make things worse. Right now, if you buy a phone and it ends up on the blacklist after the return period, you can find a service that changes the IMEI or figure it out yourself if you can stand to wade through forum FUD. Since a significant number of blacklisted phones are from broken finance contracts, a phone simply being in the blacklist does not imply that it was stolen - a broken finance contract is a civil matter purely between the carrier and the original owner. Therefore, rewriting the IMEI on such a phone is completely legal, at least in the US. Whereas if phones had titles, then a financed phone could have a legal encumbrance recorded on that title after you thought you'd bought it outright, and changing the IMEI to get out from that would be illegal. Phones are not incorporeal, immovable, expensive, or dangerous devices. Lacking all of the usual justifications for existing title systems, heading away from draconian registration makes more sense than heading towards it.
- mindslight 6y agoWhen I did live in the city, I never had my bike stolen. But that's also because I didn't do things like ride my nicer road bike for a night out, but rather had a $40 beater with a lock that cost a similar amount. Also I avoided weak poles, and always took the front wheel off. Bikes are actually a great analogy. Even though bike thefts are a concern, I still wouldn't want any of my bikes to have a built in location tracking to discourage theft! I'd rather suffer the mitigations I mentioned above, and consider losing a beater bike as part of the cost of transportation, than have my movements permanently recorded. Similarly, I did and still do have no problem carrying a few hundred dollars cash. In general, remaining an autonomous individual requires being in possession of things of value that you control. Relying on some overarching system to take care of them for you results in that system inherently controlling you.
- josephcsible 6y ago> Errr, to be clear, the reason that phones don’t get stolen is that there are anti-theft measures in place. Activation lock actually helps to reduce phone theft, but IMEI blacklisting is basically totally worthless. It's way too easy to change a phone's IMEI for it to be useful, and you often don't even have to do that, since just taking the phone to a foreign country is often enough to evade the blacklist.