3 ms·
Anti-theft. The device itself needs an identifier, so that if someone steals your device—immediately turning it off, re-flashing the OS, and putting their SIM i
by derefr 6y ago
Anti-theft. The device itself needs an identifier, so that if someone steals your device—immediately turning it off, re-flashing the OS, and putting their SIM in it, before booting it back up—then the network will still have some identifier to recognize the device itself by, so that it can say “nope, that’s stolen” and refuse to let it onto the network (thus disincentivizing stealing cellphones in the first place.)
I believe network-IMEI-registration isn’t the primary mechanism by which modern phone anti-theft works by, though, since the device-owner is free to change the phone’s network-reported IMEI (much like you can change an Ethernet controller’s network-reported MAC address.) I might be wrong here, though; the phone’s baseband might come up with its burned-in IMEI and check for validity with the server, before switching to any application-processor-requested IMEI. (You can get around that by just booting up the phone in a Faraday cage—but having to do that every time would definitely decrease the black-market resale value.)
For iOS, at least, I think the anti-theft works by getting onto wi-fi each time the SIM changes and asking some activation server about the validity of [some other internal static device-ID that can’t be tampered with in this way]. Not so sure what, if anything, Android does (Android’s case is harder, since for phones with an unlocked bootloader, you can always flash an altered firmware that has no anti-theft logic.)
- mindslight 6y agoThe same anti-theft argument could be used to justify building surveillance tech into any object, and yet our society seems to function just fine without it. I've never had my phone stolen, and I don't know anybody who has even just lost their phone more than once. Yet we all get tracked every single day due to this user-hostile design. Also for most phones it's trivial to change the IMEI to resell the phone, or simply part it out. Which sure, are more things manufacturers see as bugs, to the frustration of legitimate activity - hence Right to Repair. The majority of the world is honest. Let's not build ourselves into a prison just to fallaciously protect against the few who aren't.
- derefr 6y ago> I've never had my phone stolen, and I don't know anybody who has even just lost their phone more than once. Errr, to be clear, the reason that phones don’t get stolen is that there are anti-theft measures in place. People steal similar types of item (e.g. car stereos, game consoles, Blu-ray players) all the time. There’s no reason other than anti-theft measures that phones as a type of item would be stolen any less than these other categories. (They’d actually be stolen far more, since they’re small/easy to slip into one’s clothes/not a weird thing to be carrying around; and are often found just left on tables at cafes or hanging out of people’s back pockets. They’re like cash, basically.) It’s the same reason that people steal bicycles more often than they steal cars. Bicycles, despite being worth much less, are just much easier to steal. > The majority of the world is honest. Do you live in a city? I’ve had my bicycle stolen five times now. I’ve also been mugged twice. I’ve never had my phone stolen, though—because it’s worthless to the sort of dumb criminals who steal things just to hawk them on the street, rather than to fence them. It doesn’t require a large fraction of the world to be dishonest, to result in most people in the world having crimes committed against them. A thief will steal from far more than one person in their thieving career. Especially in regimes where the computed ROI for going after certain types of thief (e.g. homeless, drug-addicted thieves) is negative (i.e. their prison housing costs society more than their thieving does, apparently), and so they’re never held for more than a day or two.
- sudosysgen 6y agoTrust me, the #1 reason why phones don't get stolen is because they are physically difficult to steal. If a well-connected thief steals your phone (and there are a lot of well-connected thieves), they will not have much of an issue getting them sold. Then the phone will either be parted out or flashed out of any anti-theft, depending on market demand.
- derefr 6y agoThere are two types of thieves: thieves that operate as part of a professional thieving ring; and thieves that operate alone, intending to directly hawk/pawn/trade/use what they’ve stolen. Most thefts are committed by thieves who operate alone. (This is verifiable at least for my own country; I asked a crime-statistics analyst friend of mine.) Thus, most deterrence is focused on deterring the thieves who act alone. This is the same reason that “security locks” aren’t actually proof against professional thieves. They’re not meant to deter thieving rings; they’re just meant to deter the thieves who are acting alone. Such thieves might have watched a tutorial or two on YouTube on lock-picking, and they might have picked up a lock-picking set from AliExpress; but they don’t have (and aren’t willing/able to invest in) the sort of lock-picking skills/tools that professionals have (e.g. slide-hammers, impact drivers, etc.) so an average security lock will be enough to stymie them. Same with clubs on cars: no proof against professional thieving rings, but good enough to make a thief acting alone look elsewhere. Just like there is a qualitative difference in how people treat things that are “free” vs. “$0.01”, there is a qualitative difference in theft rates between “no security” and “trivial security.” Most property crimes are spur-of-the-moment, committed by people who didn’t come prepared to steal something, but just see an opportunity to take something and feel the need to have it. Put a trivial barrier in the way of taking things, and those spur-of-the-moment crimes committed by “amateur thieves” go away.
- sudosysgen 6y agoThe vast majority of stolen phones see their parts sold. Of those that don't, I know of a few people in major phone theft hubs that will change your IMEI (to name them, Derb Ghlef in Morocco, though I am sure it is also done in Shezhen and other such similar places). How they do it exactly I am not sure, I imagine that involves flashing the baseband through JTAG connectors. In any case, that is quite a cheap process. You will notice this happen - If your phone is stolen in Europe, it will almost invariably end up later in North Africa, then disappear entirely shortly after. Similar stories for stolen phones in NA, I'm sure. As for iOS anti-theft, that also can be defeated in various ways. In any case, anti-theft is not a proper justification for IMEIs being unique. Any anti-theft in a device that has been integrally stolen will be bypassed. These phones get fenced to people in third world countries with very very good reverse-engineering and electronics skills, and it only takes one to find out how to bypass any given issue. And worse comes to worst, they will sell the parts and still make a few hundred dollars out of your phone.