5 ms·
Very nice! I presume the phones still work too, otherwise this would have been caught much sooner. The existence of the IMEI is, at this point, a deliberate sec
by mindslight 6y ago
Very nice! I presume the phones still work too, otherwise this would have been caught much sooner. The existence of the IMEI is, at this point, a deliberate security flaw that has been pushed onto us by governmental standards bodies, and cemented into law. A secure mobile protocol would not have fixed identifiers, and would instead identify endpoints with a nonce that rotated over time and base station.
- jrockway 6y agoI agree. Vendors are perfectly happy to randomize MAC addresses when scanning for WiFi access points, but apparently not willing to use the same algorithm when connecting to the cell network. I get that it makes many things easier when you have a persistent unique ID, but it is by no means required to control access to the physical layer. You can just randomly generate a number, and then authenticate with actual credentials.
- sudosysgen 6y agoIndeed. There is no valid technical reason for IMEIs to be unique, except for already very tenuous anti-theft perpetuation which is really a very minor factor.
- mschuster91 6y agoNot to forget the surveillance stingrays. They (and dragnet data fishing) become useless with rotating device identifiers.
- opless 6y agoStingrays tend to capture both IMEI and IMSI. This is GSM, which is used by 99% of the world. IMSI then can be taken to the carrier and the account holder details will be released by a warrant. An IMEI (which in most countries it will be illegal to change/clone) only identifies the hardware. So swapping SIMs between phones don’t help to do anything apart from identifying a number of phones that you have access to. 3/4/5G phones will always drop back to 2G if it sees a 2G service whilst 3/4/5G frequencies are jammed. So you need to realise that phones by design are tracking devices, and stock up on those burner phones and never switch them on near your home :)
- sudosysgen 6y agoIn truth though, it is not very difficult to get a hold of an IMSI that does not refer to you, via an anonymous SIM cards you can get a hold of a few different ways. And it is not very difficult to find the maintenance service menu of your phone and disable everything except 4G and 5G either. However, it is much simpler to just leave your SIM card at home and use other means of access :)
- opless 6y agoNot all phones have access to baseband controls, and I’ve never seen a “turn off 2G” option, but yes you can turn off 3/4G. It’s easy to get a burner phone in some countries, but many you need a passport or government-issued ID to even get a prepaid SIM! Let alone a phone! Governments really don’t like citizenry to be anonymous.
- sudosysgen 6y agoFor example on my LG V30, I can go to the dialer and enter : *#*#4636#*#* I can then go into "Phone info" and set the radio to "LTE only" or "LTE/WCDMA", and if there is no 2G/3G/etc... I will not be have any service. [1] This also works for most android phones, with small exceptions. [1] : https://ibb.co/JvZVHXF https://ibb.co/JvZVHXF
- opless 6y agoNot all phones are android;)
- sudosysgen 6y agoPresumably someone that really cares about privacy would use an Android :)
- opless 6y agoIf someone really cared about privacy, you’d not be using cellular technologies at all ;)