6 ms·
If you're old enough, you might have noticed a pattern. 1. BIG NEWS: Resource X is running out! 2. Years later: BIG NEWS: Resource X is miraculously not runni
by BurningFrog 6y ago
If you're old enough, you might have noticed a pattern.
1. BIG NEWS: Resource X is running out!
2. Years later: BIG NEWS: Resource X is miraculously not running out!
I'm not saying that always happens and nothing ever runs out. But it's common enough that I put these in the "I'll believe it when I see it" file.
No one ever sold a paper or a click on a "THINGS ARE PROBABLY OK!" headline.
- sxp 6y agoFor even more fun, dig into the sources of any articles with the "Resource X is running out!". E.g, this BBC article about Helium prices from Septh 2019: https://www.bbc.com/news/business-49715838 https://www.bbc.com/news/business-49715838 Then dig into the numbers behind the articles which tend to be weakly sourced and full of anecdotes rather than data. From that BBC article: > At the auction, the average price for crude helium rose a whopping 135% year-on-year as industrial users acted to boost stocks for future years. > "It wasn't very difficult for major suppliers to pass this increase on to their customers, so it did affect worldwide pricing," says [Phil Kornbluth, the founder of Kornbluth Helium Consulting, which advises clients on commercial aspects of the global helium business, says the "price has gone up an awful lot in a short space of time"]. So there's a single source and it's someone who benefits from the price going up. The Physics Today article has more data, but it still has too many anecdotes and could be mostly replaced by a chart of supply & demand trends over time like the one in the linked report: https://www.edisongroup.com/wp-content/uploads/2019/02/HeliumMacroUpdate2019.pdf https://www.edisongroup.com/wp-content/uploads/2019/02/Heliu... While helium is going to remain a non-renewable resource until we can mine the sun, there is no critical shortage in the immediate future.
- gridlockd 6y agoWe actually ran out of oil reserves when the price dropped to zero earlier this year, because reserves are defined as "oil that can be extracted at cost at current market prices". It didn't make the headlines because "oil reserves depleted" would sound illogical while gasoline is cheap.
- gxon 6y agoIf the boy cries wolf, but nobody else sees it, how do you decide if the boy was mistaken/lied or if the act of the entire town waking up scared the wolf away?
- gxon 6y agoTo expand on this, it's tempting to dismiss those warning of doom and gloom when you start to notice a pattern of the doom never materializing. But we should also be aware of the possibility that those warning of doom and gloom activate people's minds to severity and risk of the problem. Because more people are aware and paying attention, we collectively take action to mitigate the risk and the worst case never happens. A great example is our response to a pandemic. The response that creates the least amount of damage might look like a major over-reaction and people will start to question those who raised alarm with such intensity. How do we deal with this meta problem?
- BurningFrog 6y ago"Why are you dieting? You're not fat!" ...is a version of this fallacy. Rationalists probably have a name for it.