4 ms·
Definitely. Police unions are a major obstacle to removing bad apples from the police, and to changing police culture. And yet... Management (either police c
by AnimalMuppet 6y ago
Definitely. Police unions are a major obstacle to removing bad apples from the police, and to changing police culture. And yet...
Management (either police chiefs or politicians) can push police into things that are not safe for the police officers. There needs to be somebody to push back that's bigger than the individual officers.
- Avicebron 6y agoI feel like this could end badly, like I feel about the rampant efforts I'm hearing about to "defund the police". Yes, maybe less structural protection and military grade hardware might help. But conversely, non-unionized jobs can easily turn into mills for low skilled, unmotivated people. If there is no nuance to this, are we going to end up with a deteriorated police force scrounging for anyone willing to run into a fight and start shooting. I think an over correction here would be very costly long term. Once a union is gone, getting it back has historically been..challenging.
- AnimalMuppet 6y agoWell, TFA gives the example of Camden. 8 years ago they fired all the unionized cops and hired a new force. Now those new cops are unionized... but with a different contract that gives the union less power.
- adamsea 6y agoWhat’s the problem with defunding the police? Take 3/4 of their budget. Put 1/4 in community development (so people might actually be able to get jobs or a decent future) 1/4 in mental health, and 1/4 in community-based, nonviolent conflict de-escalation and resolution. See what happens. Or, you know, keep watching videos of cops shove 75-year old men onto the concrete or murder unarmed black American citizens while their police buddies stand by and twiddle their thumbs. [edit: as recent video evidence conclusively shows, the police are already full of people who are ready to start a fight and come in shooting. And police unions are enablers of that criminal activity.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- gnusty_gnurc 6y agoIt's a utopian gamble contradicting every lesson of human history and culture - namely that evil cannot be eradicated. The idea that social workers will eradicate crime is so foolish, that I'm absolutely bewildered this is being offered. By (what I can only assume) humanities majors! The irony!
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- RhysU 6y agoA dark thought: Posit that some fraction of all people (of all backgrounds) are irreparably evil. Where can civilization best harness their skills to minimize the harm to rest of humanity?
- adamsea 6y agoWhy even posit that to begin with, when we have plenty of science - psychology, sociology, behavioral economics, etc - that are intensely interested in human behavior? We have actual data and reasonably useful models to draw on. What you describe is the setting for a Young Adult fantasy series. Which is fine, and interesting for a while, but not a good way to think about how we would like our society to function. Go read Hannah Arendt's "On Violence", if you haven't. Or "Eichmann in Jerusalem." It's the banality of evil that's the really unsettling thing.
- adamsea 6y agoYou are the utopian, You live in a fantasy world where you imagine that police forces in America serve to uphold law and protect the public. Black Americans, as a group, have made it abundantly clear that they in fact feel threatened by the police as they currently exist. If the police don't treat everybody equally, how can you ever really trust them? Lastly, shame on you for exercising tired stereotype of the humanities. The Founding Fathers studied the humanities.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- scarface74 6y agoBut conversely, non-unionized jobs can easily turn into mills for low skilled, unmotivated people. How would that would be worse than what we have now?
- AnthonyMouse 6y ago> There needs to be somebody to push back that's bigger than the individual officers. We do have that. It's Congress. It's the same thing that keeps private sector employers from forcing non-union employees to endanger their lives. And if that fails, they still have the option of last resort -- quit. They're not in the military. They can walk away at any time and get a job at another police force with better leadership, and those kinds of resignations are just what it takes to get the media attention necessary to change bad policy.
- AnimalMuppet 6y agoI feel that the police need a bit more than the OSHA rules. The police walk into an environment that OSHA rules are quite inadequate for.
- AnthonyMouse 6y agoThere isn't any reason the legislature can't have safety rules specifically for the police. They have safety rules specifically for the oil industry and the airline industry etc.