4 ms·
The EPA declined to regulate perchlorate because, among other things, it’s not found in very many water systems and is naturally occurring in the southwest. (Wh
by rayiner 6y ago
The EPA declined to regulate perchlorate because, among other things, it’s not found in very many water systems and is naturally occurring in the southwest. (When the EPA tested thousands of systems in 2011, under the Obama administration, just 0.62% had perchlorate levels about the EPA recommended limit: https://www.federalregister.gov/documents/2011/02/11/2011-2603/drinking-water-regulatory-determination-on-perchlorate. https://www.federalregister.gov/documents/2011/02/11/2011-26...)
Instead, EPA has been pursing less formal measures to reduce perchlorate in the specific drinking water systems where it has been found: https://www.epa.gov/newsreleases/epa-notes-successes-reducing-perchlorate-drinking-water https://www.epa.gov/newsreleases/epa-notes-successes-reducin...
As one of “those people” who thinks it’s harmful to have a national regulation where a more local one will do, I don’t see the problem with this. There are many kinds of pollution that are national in nature, but drinking water is actually fairly localized. There is no evidence perchlorate pollution migrates great distances, so why do we need an nationwide regulation?
It should be noted that drinking water systems are almost entirely run by public entities, and already face massive funding challenges. When the EPA sets maximum allowable levels of a pollutant, it triggers a huge bureaucratic framework that everyone must follow. Is it unreasonable to decide that we don’t need to force everyone to go that far for a chemical that appears in possibly concerning levels in less than 1% of systems?
This is an excellent example of how even the slightest push back on the notion that the federal government should regulate anything and everything is treated by the media as a crisis of epic proportions. You didn’t know what perchlorate was before this article, and it doesn’t affect 99% of water systems out there, but the EPA declining to create nationwide monitoring and enforcement framework for the chemical is somehow “madness.”
- ianlevesque 6y agoYour confidence that underfunded local governments have the expertise to know which chemicals they should ignore and for what reasons is...well "optimistic" is the nicest word I could find.
- rayiner 6y agoExcept that’s not what’s happening. EPA has set a recommended perchlorate standard, at 15 micrograms per liter. In 2011, it studied thousands of public water systems to look at perchlorate levels: https://www.federalregister.gov/documents/2011/02/11/2011-2603/drinking-water-regulatory-determination-on-perchlorate https://www.federalregister.gov/documents/2011/02/11/2011-26.... Just 0.62% of those systems had perchlorate levels above 15 micrograms per liter. 96% were under 4 micrograms per liter. The EPA isn’t leaving it to local governments whether to test or to decide what the levels should be. They’re concluding that, based on testing they already did, there is no need to require formal monitoring of perchlorate in every water system just because a tiny minority of systems have concerning levels of the chemical. And it’s handling those exceptions on a case-by-case basis.
- moron4hire 6y agoSo what? So those places don't have to do anything. Having the standard doesn't cost them anything.
- Scramblejams 6y agoThat's unlikely to be true. Standards commonly beget all kinds of bureaucracy and effort downstream. Sensible-sounding regulations (e.g. "we should certify that our city's water systems comply with all relevant EPA standards!") conspire with "no-cost-you're-already-meeting-this" standards to increase the burden of documentation, verification, certification and so on. And maybe that's fine! But the supposition that the EPA setting a standard relevant to tens of thousands of municipal water districts will generate zero costs for those municipalities glosses over how the bureaucratic wheels turn.
- rayiner 6y agoThere is already a recommendation in place, it’s 15 micrograms per milliliter. This regulatory proceeding was about establishing a NPDWR, which triggers a whole host of new requirements. Once a NPDWR is created for a chemical, it flips the burden of proof. The EPA must set the MCLG at a “at which no known or anticipated adverse effect on the health of persons would occur.” Note that the EPA has to prove a negative—and has to do so under a regulatory process where any decision will be subject to years of litigation. The EPA must then set an MCL that gets as close to the MCLG using “the best available control technology.” Even if this process doesn’t result in an MCL that’s unrealistically low, it triggers a whole nationwide testing regime.
- kjaftaedi 6y agoI can only assume you live near an estuary. Do you really believe that water pollution is only a problem to be handled by people who are downstream and not a shared responsibility?
- rayiner 6y agoI live on the Chesapeake Bay, the country’s largest estuary. (I’m staring out my window at the water right now.) Of course I believe that water pollution is a shared responsibility—much of the silt in the Bay comes from agricultural operations in New Jersey and Pennsylvania. But the EPA continues to push along NY/NJ/PA into meeting their 2025 TMDL targets for run-off into the Bay. Phosphorus and nitrogen from agricultural activities is the archetypal example of something that must be regulated at the federal level, and Wheeler doesn’t deny it. (There is an ongoing spat about whether the TMDLs are directly enforceable against the states, but the EPA’s current position was formulated during the Obama administration.) But what doesn’t come floating down the river is perchlorate. Accepting that the EPA must regulate certain types of water pollution doesn’t mean that all water pollution must be regulated at the federal level.
- naasking 6y ago> Do you really believe that water pollution is only a problem to be handled by people who are downstream and not a shared responsibility? That's not what he said. He said perchlorate pollution in water does not necessitate national regulation given the data. That says nothing about other chemicals which may disperse more widely or whose use is so common as to contaminate many water systems.
- redeux 6y agoIt’s possible to have a federal regulation that only targets problems areas. The Voting Rights Act of 1965 is a classic example.
- perl4ever 6y agoBut...it proved not to be possible: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shelby_County_v._Holder https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shelby_County_v._Holder
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- Ididntdothis 6y agoMaybe we should eliminate nationwide regulations on theft and violence too? Let the locals deal with these things since they are local issues. That way municipalities with funding problems could save some money.
- rayiner 6y agoThat is, in fact, what we do. If you steal something or kill someone, unless you’re on federal land, you’re prosecuted by the state under state law.
- Ididntdothis 6y agoInteresting. Can a state or a county decide that killing people or bank robbery is OK? I am honestly curious.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- bloudermilk 6y agoSure, depending on the scenario. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stand-your-ground_law#United_States https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stand-your-ground_law#United_S...
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- monadic2 6y ago0.62% is pretty alarming, tbh. Our water systems are generally much less safe than people believe.
- rayiner 6y agohttps://www.washingtonpost.com/news/to-your-health/wp/2018/01/03/raw-water-is-the-latest-health-craze-heres-why-drinking-it-may-be-a-bad-idea/ https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/to-your-health/wp/2018/0... > All in all, “we have an incredibly safe and reliable water supply” in the United States, said David Jones, professor of history of medicine at Harvard Medical School.
- monadic2 6y agoIncredibly is right! I'm curious how they arrive at that conclusion—what's an acceptable amount of harm to justify infrastructure neglect? The article you linked appears to be about comparing treated water to "raw water", which seems rather tangential to our discussion of considering the quality of treated water. I'm just saying, a lot of people have implicit trust in their water without even knowing what's in it or why 0.62% of americans with perchlorate are somehow clumped in with the americans who are lucky to not have it in their water—surely this would be a success because only 0.62% of water needed extra infrastructure investment and regulation? After all, perchlorate is unlikely to remain at such a low penetration with continued use....