3 ms·
> Antitrust actions under US doctrine are supposed to benefit consumers Note that the viewpoint that antitrust is SOLELY about benefit to consumers, and not al
by hn_throwaway_99 6y ago
> Antitrust actions under US doctrine are supposed to benefit consumers
Note that the viewpoint that antitrust is SOLELY about benefit to consumers, and not also about restricting corporate power, is relatively new in US antitrust jurisprudence (around the 80s I think), and there are currently many scholars reassessing this viewpoint.
Edit: Some more info about current reassessment of the Chicago School of Antitrust: https://www.law.uchicago.edu/news/reassessing-chicago-school-antitrust-law https://www.law.uchicago.edu/news/reassessing-chicago-school...
- ls612 6y agoIt’s a very complicated issue but I thought one of the justifications behind that doctrine was that consumer benefits/prices was a very objective way to measure corporate power (because with lots of power they would be able to raise prices freely to hurt consumers and benefit themselves)
- jeffbee 6y agoChicago School antitrust doctrine has been the direction of US jurisprudence throughout the existence of the online advertising industry and predates all of the market participants. Even if we throw it out, what's _any_ ethical, moral, or legal reason to break up Google's business? Surely it can't be that the government has an interest in boosting Verizon's market share.
- topkai22 6y agoThere used to be a pretty strong belief in the separation of media production and distribution, originating in the break up of the studio system. I'm not a historian or legal expert here by any stretch, but at some of the arguments supporting this were about ensuring the limited platforms (movie studios and broadcasters at the time) would have to allow competitive access for distribution of content. Google is in a position similar to being a major broadcaster- it is a gatekeeper of content, whether through search, YouTube, or ads. While Google started off with a pretty radical view of free speech that resulted on a pretty content, that has waned in the last 5-10 years. The most obvious of this is the de-monetization of YouTube channels. While I hardly disagree with their choice to distance themselves from many vitriolic personalities, I've also seen them demonetize science channels for doing experiments involving explosives and smaller channels they just didn't want to bother monitoring. The theoretical reason for this- their ad partners don't want their ads accidently running on offensive content.* There isn't any real alternative to YouTube. Searching for how to videos on google often results in a page of only YouTube videos. Content producers cannot directly negotiate interstitial ad content. The old-time concerns about a single broadcaster dominating the marketplace of ideas is absolutely applicable here. Breaking up Content, Search, and Ads would go a long way to ensure access to the platform. *As well they should, and I actually kind of LIKE that its become harder for offensive crazies to make money, but I'm providing the argument for breaking up the content, search, and ads.
- johncolanduoni 6y agoWouldn’t an independent YouTube have the same problem? They would still be beholden to the companies purchasing the ad space and demonetize channels that risk upsetting those advertisers.
- topkai22 6y agoNot if they were required to allow content creators to utilize alternate ad platforms to inject ads before or after the run. Sure they'd still have the option to kick the creators out of search or off the platform entirely, but that potentially enables alternative hosting platforms. There used to be (and might still be) limits on how much national advertising national networks could require local stations to carry, on the theory this made local stations more independent (and in tune with local needs). This is my 21st century version of that regulation. Like I said, I'm not even sure I'm in favor of such a break up, but I can see the historical parallels.