3 ms·
How are vacuums, pure functions or abstract concepts state machines? Philosophy has some pretty well fleshed out concepts around simple objects (without proper
by jayd16 6y ago
How are vacuums, pure functions or abstract concepts state machines?
Philosophy has some pretty well fleshed out concepts around simple objects (without proper parts) and intrinsic properties as well that I think would contradict this.
- rantwasp 6y agothe short answer that you’re not going to like is that everything you’re describing is a human construction. it therefore exists in the minds of people as a concept. we use it because it’s convenient. a pure function that does not exist anywhere and nobody does not know about effectively does not exist. philosophy is another things that is a human construction. a lot of our lives is lived inside our heads working with things we made up. it’s convention. you don’t get to ignore physics.
- jayd16 6y agoWell I think this is surely a cop out as a state machine is also a concept. Although If you are conceding we can't model all concepts with state machines then I think I'm satisfied.
- rantwasp 6y agohahaha. oh nooo. you’re not satisfied :) the initial discussion was about all physical object. since you cannot have concepts without representing them onto something physical (paper, in the memory of a computer, in brain, etc) it immediately follows that concepts exist only with a state machine substrate. therefore concepts, distilled to their essential components are (insanely large insanely distributed) state machines