4 ms·
> A new trans-pennine rail tunnel from Liverpool-Manchester-Sheffield under the peaks, and Manc-Leeds-Hull would add vastly more value than a faster connection
by chrisseaton 6y ago
> A new trans-pennine rail tunnel from Liverpool-Manchester-Sheffield under the peaks, and Manc-Leeds-Hull would add vastly more value than a faster connection between already well connected cities.
I live in this area and do these routes frequently and yes I'd love them to be more connected too.
But realistically, like almost everyone else in the country almost all my travel is to and from London, because that's where most things happen.
- reallydontask 6y agoCould this not be because of lack of said transport links on an East-West Axis? I can't help but feel that if the trains had dedicated business carriages with reliable internet access, nobody would be all that fussed to get to London 20 to 30 minutes quicker edit: I don't mean First Class. I mean something like an all tables carriage or even just a fold down tables that can easily accommodate a 17" laptop (even if not many people have them, the space is what I'm after)
- chrisseaton 6y ago> Could this not be because of lack of said transport links on an East-West Axis? The majority of the nation's key institutions are in London. How does improving an East-West axis improve access to them, or encourage them to move? > I can't help but feel that if the trains had dedicated business carriages with reliable internet access There are dedicated business carriages on London trains. The internet isn't fantastic but it's fine. But I'd rather not be on the train long enough to need it.
- oakesm9 6y agoCould it not be that most institutions are in London _because_ of those good connections. The idea is to improve connects between different cities which will make it viable for companies to be located there.
- chrisseaton 6y agoThis doesn't make any sense - for an institution to move from London to Leeds you don't need one line from Manchester to Leeds, you need a line from everywhere to Leeds.
- diroussel 6y agoYep, and a good line from Liverpool and Manchester to Leeds would be a very good start. As then you good access to Leeds from many of the highly populated areas of the UK.
- vidarh 6y agoThat depends, there are multiple considerations: One is access for "everyone". Many don't need that. The other is access to a large enough labour pool. That said, the easiest way for government to use government departments for district development policies, is to simply move them. E.g. this is where the Norwegian equivalent of Companies House plus assorted similar registries is located: https://www.google.com/maps/place/Br%C3%B8nn%C3%B8ysundregistrene/@65.4763472,12.2101879,17z/data=!3m1!4b1!4m5!3m4!1s0x46749b9bc542efc9:0x602073e770daa0fd!8m2!3d65.4763472!4d12.2123766 https://www.google.com/maps/place/Br%C3%B8nn%C3%B8ysundregis... If you zoom out you'll notice there are no major cities nearby.The nearest major city - Trondheim - is ~6h-7h drive South. It's smaller than Nottingham. Norway has "just" relocated government departments out of Oslo as an intentional policy for decades, and it takes effort but it generally works quite well. Transport policy then follows depending on how this changes transport patterns, rather than lead.
- bluGill 6y agoThat depends on what institution is moving. Some just need a good link to Manchester, and so will be more willing to move. Some need to get everywhere and will wait. It depends on what the pros and cons of each city are. As to if enough will move given any particular link, that is a hard question requiring complex studies and so cannot be answered.
- reallydontask 6y ago> The majority of the nation's key institutions are in London. How does improving an East-West axis improve access to them, or encourage them to move? If transport links are good between Liverpool, Manchester, Sheffield, Leeds and maybe Hull then you have a significant pool of people available to work in any of those locations, though bigger pool is going to be Manchester, Sheffield and Leeds. This could encourage a move as the transport links to London are already pretty good. > There are dedicated business carriages on London trains. The internet isn't fantastic but it's fine. You might not have seen my edit, I didn't mean First Class. The internet access was, until 2018 when I was on the trains regularly, pretty, pretty bad, even in First class. Constant drops, issues sending emails, etc ... > But I'd rather not be on the train long enough to need it. It's not about need is about using the time productively. I could be on the train to London and use the close to two hours to catch up on emails and do a lot of admin. Essentially for me, it was the difference between attending a customer meeting in London, then spending the next day catching up and just having a normal day the day after the meeting. One of my guys refused to work on the train as he would get motion sickness, so clearly YMMV
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- logifail 6y ago> nobody would be all that fussed to get to London 20 to 30 minutes quicker I don't think people are that fussed. From QZ.com[0]: "In the mornings, a train leaves London for Birmingham approximately every 15 minutes. The 7:23 am fast train leaves Euston and arrives at New Street station one hour and 22 minutes later, at 8:45 am—this would be shortened to 45 minutes with HS2. The train is full of commuters and business travelers with a confusing range of opinions about HS2. Most point out that the journey from London to Birmingham is already quite fast. 'We have this train, so I question why we need it,' says Ben Brown, who commutes to Birmingham two to three times a week. 'It’s not as if the train that we’re in…is particularly slow,' echoes Damon Lacey, a human relations consultant from Portsmouth." [0] https://qz.com/1803712/birmingham-shows-why-the-uks-hs2-plans-are-so-controversial/ https://qz.com/1803712/birmingham-shows-why-the-uks-hs2-plan...
- diroussel 6y agoYes it goes to Birmingham, but it's not for Birmingham. It just so happens that Birminghan is on the route to the North.
- M2Ys4U 6y agoOkay, now here's the next paragraph: >Proponents of HS2 will point out ad nauseam that the point isn’t the journey time; it’s the increased capacity that a new railway will bring, allowing faster trains to shift on to their own track, and rendering the network more efficient. “We’ve been working off Victorian infrastructure on our national rail network and demand is increasing at an unprecedented scale, and we need more capacity,” explains Adam Tyndall, program director for transport at London First, a business advocacy group.
- scatters 6y agoHS2 isn't about making journeys faster, it's about adding capacity. If you're building a new line, you may as well make it high speed; higher speeds mean more capacity since you can run trains closer together in time for a particular separation; and you require less machinery, staff and stabling space since each trainset can make more runs per day.
- reallydontask 6y ago>if you're building a new line, you may as well make it high speed; All things being equal, sure, but a high speed line is going to be more expensive, specially at the speeds required. I'm not sure that any potential changes in working patterns given covid-19 will be taken into consideration but they should. In any case, we'll no doubt fall into sunk cost fallacy territory soon and it will be £100Bn before this is done
- gmac 6y agoDefinitely agree — I suspect the (highly suspect) CBA that was used to justify HS2 would come out a lot less positive with the amount of extra home-working we can expect post-COVID-19.
- M2Ys4U 6y agoEven if people work from home more, we will still want to shift freight from road to rail, and the WCML is full.
- improbable22 6y ago>if you're building a new line, you may as well make it high speed; I think the thing to understand here is that mixing speeds is awful for capacity. There are some fast trains now, and everything else has to be scheduled around them, which means they each eat up many slots, to clear the line a safe distance ahead. There's lots of demand for more slow trains, which can't be run. If you built a new slow line, you would still have this problem. And the slow trains want to stop many places, so you can't build the line through open fields, and building through towns is really expensive. So you build a new fast line. And then it may as well go a little faster than the existing fast trains. But this increment isn't the main point. Or at least that's my understanding. I don't doubt the price will grow. I have also heard there may have been other not-quite-as-fast options, refurbishing a disused line instead?
- randomsearch 6y agoPossibly mixing causing and effect here!!! Fast train routes in the north will allow Manchester to become a replacement for most things people go to London for.
- chrisseaton 6y ago> Possibly mixing causing and effect here!!! This is an unhelpfully abstract way to look at things. It doesn't matter what caused London to be the centre of the universe for UK society. What matters is that it currently is. > Fast train routes in the north will allow Manchester to become a replacement for most things people go to London for. The problem you're missing is that you don't need fast routes in the north, you'd need fast routes to the north, from everywhere, as you currently have with London, if you want to compete. You don't one new train line to Manchester, you need the thirteen or so routes in London has. And then you also need a serious airport.
- rjsw 6y ago> And then you also need a serious airport. What is wrong with Manchester Airport ? It is the next busiest after Heathrow and Gatwick and already has two runways.
- chrisseaton 6y ago> What is wrong with Manchester Airport ? It's a joke. Cramped, dirty, unprofessional. I'm embarrassed when I ask colleagues to fly into it. The terminals are packed with bloody fruit machines. Massive smoking areas blocking all the entrances. Weird half-shut-down roads to the terminals. No decent dining or bar options. The security screening seems to be done in a dungeon about three stories underground. The terminals were cut in half in a strange way to accomodate changes to international I think so they're now a depressing maze and you have to go down steps into a basement to go from one side of the corridor to the other. Most of the terminals don't have a proper business lounge. I don't think there's a BA first-class lounge at all! The flag carrier has no first lounge! It's not even very useful - few serious international routes. It doesn't have direct flights to essential business destinations like San Francisco. There's not even a flight to Washington DC anymore as far as I know! It just isn't a serious international airport. I fly to all these incredible places around the world and come back into Manchester (via somewhere else as nothing is direct) and every time I think 'wow what a grimy, amateur operation - how embarrassing is it that this is all we can achieve'. Not joking - I sometimes recommend colleagues fly into Heathrow and take the train so they don't get this first impression. I guess maybe it's third in the UK, but it's like 1% of what Heathrow is.