9 ms·
The UK is exposing very little of its workforce to great tunnelling projects, because very little of HS2 is about tunnelling, and most of the rest of the techno
by TheOtherHobbes 6y ago
The UK is exposing very little of its workforce to great tunnelling projects, because very little of HS2 is about tunnelling, and most of the rest of the technology is being bought in anyway.
This repeats an old pattern. The UK used to have a nationalised rail system with world-class R&D. The R&D was effectively given away when the system was privatised, and then the technology was bought in when it was needed later - from foreign companies which were now charging the UK for IP it had developed at home.
Even if that weren't true, the UK would be competing in a tiny space with even larger projects - like the Brenner Base Tunnel, which is currently burrowing through 55km of solid rock under the Alps.
The reality is there is very little real payback in terms of jobs and future opportunities - certainly much less than spending the money on world class broadband infrastructure and technology training.
The infuriating thing about HS2 is that it's basically just pork for party donors dressed up as a strategic and patriotic wonder - because the ruling class just can't deal with the fact that the 19th century is over.
Meanwhile the strategic areas the UK is actually a significant player in - including plenty of science and technology, and not a little engineering, but also the arts, finance, and law - are being starved of investment, opportunity, and effective management.
- BlackVanilla 6y agoSure, I tried to make the focus of my comment on the rarely talked about benefit of skilling people up as a positive externality, rather than to give credit to HS2 specifically, but I probably didn't do this well enough. Skilling up people in the world of STEM, finance, arts are all as important, if not more so than tunnelling.
- te_chris 6y agoThe thing that I find most humourous about British Rail - as a non brit, former colonial subject, who lives in London - is that they literally invented high speed rail, then lost the ultimate prize to the French (i.e. France ran ahead with it, electrified it then rolled it out. I find this incredibly amusing as there's still a certain portion of English society with a huge chip on their shoulders vis a vis France).
- reallydontask 6y agoAlso as a non Brit who lives in the UK, I've always felt that the massive chip on the shoulder was regarding the Germans not the French but maybe it's just the people I've met
- cameronh90 6y agoWe like to make fun of the French, but it's mostly a joke.
- vixen99 6y agoMostly the English love to hear jokes against themselves.
- michaelt 6y agoBrits only have chips on their shoulder about two things: Countries they've won battles against, and countries they've lost battles against.
- 082349872349872 6y agoNo chips against Andorra, Belarus, Bolivia, Burundi, Central African Republic, Chad, Congo, Guatemala, Ivory Coast ,Kyrgyzstan, Liechtenstein, Luxembourg, Mali, Marshall Islands, Monaco, Mongolia, Paraguay, Sao Tome and Principe, Sweden, Tajikistan, Uzbekistan and Vatican City, then?
- cheerlessbog 6y agoSo there's a (small) list on Wikipedia of "countries the UK has not fought"? Do they have a shorter list than anyone else? (Am Brit)
- noir_lord 6y agoI can't think of a country that would be even close. Previous world powers came to pre-eminence when less of the world was known and later world powers are nuclear and haven't really directly invaded, fought or attacked like the British did. This map brings it home more than most https://i.redd.it/75nqzhfp42r21.png https://i.redd.it/75nqzhfp42r21.png and it only covers a single instance for many of those countries, the British (English first, rest of UK later) and the French spent most of a millennia beating each other up when they had no one else to fight - I mean Churchill gave orders to shoot French military if necessary months before the end of WW2 (between VE and VJ day) during the Levant Crisis.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- robk 6y agoNationalized rail was shit here come on.
- fold_left 6y ago> On [public ownership of] our railway, the East Coast line was run in public ownership from 2009 to 2014. It had 91% customer satisfaction and returned £1 billion to the Treasury. (Today, half of our rail services are run by foreign state owned companies.) https://weownit.org.uk/why-public-ownership/successful-examples https://weownit.org.uk/why-public-ownership/successful-examp...
- gsnedders 6y agoIn 2015–2018, the three year period of VTEC, customer satisfaction was generally unchanged from East Coast (though went down at the very end) and £800m was returned to the Treasury. Per year, that's 30% higher than the nationalised East Coast returned (and okay, ~£160m of the £800m ultimately came from Stagecoach paying more money than VTEC had operating profit, but from a taxpayer point-of-view that's irrelevant). (See https://publications.parliament.uk/pa/cm201719/cmselect/cmtrans/891/891.pdf https://publications.parliament.uk/pa/cm201719/cmselect/cmtr...)
- willyt 6y agoWhat is different now compared to before? Fares have increased faster than inflation, trains are overcrowded, the seats are a lot more cramped, just as worn and dirty, no faster than before and the sandwiches are still as bad as the ones you get in petrol stations.
- mhh__ 6y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/History_of_rail_transport_in_Great_Britain#/media/File:GBR_rail_passengers_by_year_1830-2015.png https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/History_of_rail_transport_in_G... Make of this trend what you will.
- 6y ago