3 ms·
Is work really the place for "meaningful discussions"? To me, meaningful discussions is talking about philosophy, religion, political theory, introspecting the
by skissane 6y ago
Is work really the place for "meaningful discussions"?
To me, meaningful discussions is talking about philosophy, religion, political theory, introspecting the roots of one's own psychology, etc. That's not really what work is for. At work, one needs to focus one's discussions on the job – of course, you can talk about outside work stuff, but I'm always careful to try to keep it shallow and non-controversial. I'm not about to start debating the existence of God with my work colleagues, as much as I really love that particular debate. Nor am I going to drill into the impact my parent's divorce had on my own psychological development.
- bdcravens 6y agoMeaning is based on context. "Meaningful" for work would be company policies, discussing a situation affecting a customer, discussing how to address a particular bug, etc. The "deep" topics you referenced usually aren't meaningful to the work place, even if they are to humanity in general.
- metrokoi 6y agoNaming the product "Currents" definitely gives the impression that it is at least partially meant for discussing current events. There are so many other messaging and discussion platforms for organizations, it seems like Google is going with the "use this to discuss how our organization can take advantage of social trends" angle instead of just generalized discussion of projects. That's my impression anyway. Regardless it also sounds like a great tool for company gossip and office politics.
- mav3rick 6y agoNo currents can also mean "streams", which probably implies threads of conversations.
- compsciphd 6y agoas opposed to a wave? ;)
- tibbydudeza 6y agoOuch.
- idclip 6y agoI honestly think if a product isn't going to be interpreted in one way (basic law of affordance in design) (also for the most part, some leeway allowed) - it’s A sign for faulty affordance, and an indicator to its future success.
- agumonkey 6y agoHaving just got a new job, I'm faced with the time eternal shallow work discussions which often revolves about how bored, how demotivated, how insufferable colleague-N, why me if not them ... Jobs seems ontologically based on a closed system of semi passive suffering.
- serkandurusoy 6y agoWith all due respect, I do find work - just as anywhere else - to be a place for meaningful discussions. I usually work as an engineer and manager/mentor and prefer being vulnerable with the people I support. That leads to them often choosing to be themselves. This only requires some honesty and sincerity. Once we and everyone else who choose to do the same connect on that level, such meaning shows itself in not only one on ones, but also in online chat. I also find it a boost in productivity because it allows distilling work discussions into pure work because people have to worry less about what they say/write or how they express it. One huge and rewarding benefit is also that people begin looking behind misconstruable messages, reading the discussion in positive light and helping each other communicate better, too.
- grasshopperpurp 6y agoI've had a similar experience from a different angle; I'm not over anyone, but I have engaged in conversations that cover politics, religion, philosophy, etc.. I avoid politicianX vs politicianY types of conversations for obvious reasons, but I think the restrictions are good for conversation - not so dissimilar from the restrictions on HN vs FB or Twitter. It forces me to find common ground, to listen to what people want and how they think things should work. I have found that people wildly diverge from party politics in this scenario. When we focus on the issue and hypothetical ways forward, we tend to agree on the big points - or agree in spirit, at least. When we remove the labels and the expectations that come with those labels, we can have a conversation where both sides operate in good faith. Of course, we can still have those conversations with the labels, but, in practice, we tend to get distracted by them. I had someone ask me what I thought about the riots (this was within the first couple days), and based on his background and other conversations I had with him, I knew his POV was very different from mine, but we are on friendly terms, so I engaged. Tone is important. My focus was on what we could do so that things don't reach that point, and I was empathetic toward the people he felt the worst for - business owners who lost things to the riots. And, in turn, he was empathetic to the people who suffer systematic abuses. In these scenarios, I just try to focus on understanding where the other person is coming from and to make my thoughts clear. I don't get frustrated when someone doesn't say, 'Gee, never thought of it that way, but you're absolutely right.' I think a lot of people - all over the map on the big issues - are tired of conversations that center around your mob vs my mob. They're ready to have real conversations about real issues. The depth will depend upon what each person brings to the table, but on a basic level, depth is almost beside the point. It's enough to listen to an on-paper enemy and have them listen to you and walk away understanding that you're not enemies at all, that you both want what's best for your community, city, state, country, and world. We can disagree on how to get there, but if we trust the motivations of others, we can work together. We can't work toward progress with people we don't trust, which is one of the underlying issues with starting with labels. Of course, there are people to distrust for various reasons, but if I find people who are willing to honesty discuss why they believe what they do about anything (and what they know and don't, etc.), I want to hear what they have to say. And even as I cringe at a conclusion, I want to show them respect and that I took the time to understand how they arrived. Just like anything, angle/perspective makes all the difference. This is just where I'm at - not meant to tell people how they should behave or how well my perspective meshes with their personality and experiences.
- kortilla 6y agoIs debating the existence of god really a meaningful discussion? That’s not exactly the type of debate that people react to with “oh shit, you’re right!” It sounds like intellectual masturbation, which is fun sometimes to feel “very smart” but it’s not really meaningful.
- ykevinator 6y agoDisagree, work is exactly the place for this. Religion is irrational, work is meaningful.