4 ms·
> Could someone not make the same argument about the national defense? > national defense https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_military_expendit
by mhh__ 6y ago
> Could someone not make the same argument about the national defense?
> national defense
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_military_expenditures#Total_military_spending https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_military_...
I'm not as against military spending as some people, but almost 800 billion dollars is too much
- blisterpeanuts 6y agoHow much would be appropriate? What weapons systems should be canceled? Serious question. I would agree that $800B seems ridiculously high, and yet it's not easy to tease apart what should be cut.
- starik36 6y agoKeep in mind that the personnel and benefits take up 39% of the cost.
- ludston 6y agoDeciding that would be the job of the military wouldn't it? That's how cuts usually work. If they need some random on HN to tell them how to do that then they probably shouldn't have the job in the first place.
- latch 6y agoA lot of experts argue for and against aircraft carriers. The against (or at least not so many) argument seem more compelling to this layman.
- ikeyany 6y agoWhatever funding goes to military displays at sporting events can be cut for once. We never had flyovers and 7th-inning-stretch-salutes-to-heroes 20 years ago.
- pfranz 6y agoThe argument that always comes up is that those flights are necessary because they're flight time required for training and public events are recruiting tools since we have a volunteer force. However, reducing the number of pilots/planes mean fewer training missions and reducing the military headcount reduces the need for recruitment.
- Godel_unicode 6y agoNow you're moving the goal posts. Whether paying for flyovers out of the training budget makes sense is orthogonal to how big a military we should have.
- pfranz 6y agoIf flyovers come out of training budgets it's not a cut. The whole premise was reducing unnecessary programs. That has a clear knock-on effect of reducing the need for headcount and recruiting. I'm not a fan of constant military displays at sporting events, but the argument is usually shut down very quickly as required flight-time and as recruitment. I was trying to turn that into a more productive direction.
- iancmceachern 6y agoThere is hundreds of millions in over the top research. Some of which is good stuff that moves us forward, but do we really need a Boeing X37 separate from NASA? Are we really getting our research money's worth when no one is allowed to know about, talk about, or otherwise leverage technologies developed? One of my favorite parts about Apollo and Kennedys involvement specifically is the very deliberate choice to make it a civil program. The question wasn't if we needed to put effort into demonstrating superiority in space or not. The question was to do it as a military or civil program. Point is, a country can accomplish a lot of the same things in different ways just by varying to which government agency we give resources. I would rather go to space on a peaceful, multi country mission, not on a military weapon. I also would rather give our public resources to first responders, medical workers, emts, fire fighters and other civil servants than to our military. We reap what we sow. Edited - typo
- mhh__ 6y agoThe X37 probably isn't a particularly good example. It almost definitely has nefarious abilities, but it's main purpose is probably materials science they can't test on the ISS (military gear)
- asdff 6y agoI'd take a hard look at the contractor system for one. The military industrial complex is set up to extract massive profit out of the public purse. There is no reason why the defense departments at boeing et al. shouldn't be nationalized imo.
- clairity 6y agoit's about a trillion if you consider hidden expenditures that are tied to the military. it's 10X bigger than it needs to be. spend the other $900B on infrastructure of all sorts, including healthcare and emergency readiness. the new, new deal.
- mhh__ 6y agoI assume it's more if you include the "dark" aspects (unless you're including those too) like NRO missions and CIA ops
- rayiner 6y ago$800 billion based on what? China spends $175 billion on their military. Compared to us, they get multiples in terms of manpower and infrastructure per dollar spent. Then there is Russia. As a percentage of GDP, we spend less on defense than France did in 1994, and half of what France spent in 1960.
- catalogia 6y ago> $800 billion based on what? China spends $175 billion on their military. Compared to us, they get multiples in terms of manpower and infrastructure per dollar spent. Or a fraction of the capability.. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Blue-water_navy#Classification_and_naval_hierarchy https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Blue-water_navy#Classification...