3 ms·
I think of the Unix Hater's Handbook as a kind of loving roast to Unix, that hackers of the time understood to be humorous (you know, how people complain about
by the_af 6y ago
I think of the Unix Hater's Handbook as a kind of loving roast to Unix, that hackers of the time understood to be humorous (you know, how people complain about the tools they use every day, much like people would later complain endlessly about Windows) and which was widely misunderstood later to be a real scathing attack.
It hasn't aged very well, either. "Even today, the X server turns fast computers into dumb terminals" hasn't been true for at least a couple of decades...
- msla 6y agoNo, I think it's mostly just as angry and bitter as it sounds, coming from people who backed the wrong horse (ITS, Lisp Machines, the various things Xerox was utterly determined to kill off... ) and got extremely pissy about Unix being the last OS concept standing outside of, like, VMS or IBM mainframe crap, neither of which they'd see as improvements.
- Analemma_ 6y agoJust because Unix was the last man standing, doesn't mean it's good. Bad products win in the marketplace all the time and for all kinds of reasons. In Unix's case I'd argue the damage is particularly severe because hackers have elevated Unix to a religion and insisted that all its flaws are actually virtues.
- Quekid5 6y ago> It hasn't aged very well, either. "Even today, the X server turns fast computers into dumb terminals" hasn't been true for at least a couple of decades... You're not wrong, but that's only because people wrote extensions for direct access to the graphics hardware... which obviously don't work remotely, and so aren't really in the spirit of X. It's great that that was possible, but OTOH it probably delayed the invention of something like Wayland for a decade+. It's been ages since I've used X for a remote application, but I sometimes wonder how many of them actually really still work to any reasonable degree. I remember some of them working when I last tried it, albeit with abysmal performance compared to Remote desktop, for example.
- Ekaros 6y agoIt's not great even on a local network I can use Firefox reasonably well, but I can entirely forget that on current remote working environment with VPN and SSH... And this is from land-line connection with reasonably powerful machines at both ends. A few seconds response time makes user-experience useless...
- the_af 6y agoFair enough! I wasn't really thinking of the remote use case which was indeed X's main use case when it was conceived (and which is not very relevant today for the majority of users). In any case, this was just an example. The Handbook is peppered with complaints which haven't been relevant for ages. It was written before Linux got user-friendly UIs and was widespread to almost every appliance on Earth. It was written before Linux could run AAA games. It was written before Docker. It was written before so many people knew how to program simple scripts. It was written before Windows and Apple embraced Unix. If some of these people are still living, I wonder what they think of the (tech) world today. Maybe they are still bitter, or maybe they understand how much they missed the mark ;)
- Quekid5 6y agoOh, certainly. It was really just a nitpick :).