3 ms·
It's not about users being outraged about what they can read. "Those other people are idiots and will kill us all without some rules" is a basic human conceit.
by sneak 6y ago
It's not about users being outraged about what they can read.
"Those other people are idiots and will kill us all without some rules" is a basic human conceit. These people calling for censorship on Facebook don't want to see that stuff, sure, but way more importantly they want FB to censor so that other people CAN'T read that stuff.
They think that if they shout loud enough, they will get to decide what other, more gullible/radicalized/violent/whatever people are allowed to read.
It's really condescending nonsense to claim that you know better than another adult what they should be allowed to read.
Lots of really famous/successful people are thinking along these lines lately. It's quite popular amongst the "thought leadership" set to think that Facebook has some moral obligation to play publishing cop and shut down private groups where people say things they don't like, because people other than the ones calling for censorship are so gullible and malleable and childlike that they'll turn into a terrorist if they read enough about 5G or vaccines or antifa or whatever in private FB groups or something.
A handy example is John Gruber's recent post on the matter:
https://daringfireball.net/linked/2020/06/02/schnitt-facebook https://daringfireball.net/linked/2020/06/02/schnitt-faceboo...
The correct answer to people being wrong is education, never censorship.
I defer, as always, to Heinlein:
> “Thing that got me was not her list of things she hated, since she was obviously crazy as a Cyborg, but fact that always somebody agreed with her prohibitions. Must be a yearning deep in human heart to stop other people from doing as they please. Rules, laws — always for other fellow. A murky part of us, something we had before we came down out of trees, and failed to shuck when we stood up. Because not one of those people said: "Please pass this so that I won't be able to do something I know I should stop." Nyet, tovarishchee, was always something they hated to see neighbors doing. Stop them "for their own good" — not because speaker claimed to be harmed by it.”
- commandlinefan 6y ago> they want FB to censor so that other people CAN'T read that stuff I'm having a hard time believing that they want to stop with Facebook, either. I suspect this will move on to hosting providers next.
- sneak 6y agoThere was an effort by Anonymous people to negatively affect Cloudflare in some capacity called #OpISIS due to the fact that Cloudflare generally tries to be a content-neutral pipe, and was continuing to host websites used by the Islamic State. https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2015/nov/19/cloudflare-accused-by-anonymous-helping-isis https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2015/nov/19/cloudflar... I wish there were more companies like Cloudflare.
- anonymousab 6y ago> Cloudflare generally tries to be a content-neutral pipe They did a complete 180 over the past couple of years, for particularly distasteful content (in their opinion). For better or worse.
- anonymousab 6y ago>The correct answer to people being wrong is education, never censorship. What do you do when people reject education itself as a matter of course or principle? Or can only view such attempts defensively, see them as patronizing at best, and so radicalize further as a result? Heck, even "this post is misleading" approaches, which leave the original content intact, are seen by some as a form of censorship (and definitely as propaganda to be discarded) and I don't think that's an unreasonable response based on their existing point of view. Fundamentally, if misinformation is more appealing and attractive than truths, how far can educational approaches go? If it's information junk food, then I see education helping no more than it helps for the obesity crisis - perhaps less so because that unhealthiness actually feels bad and prompts action. There's no equivalent with disinfo.
- sneak 6y ago> What do you do when people reject education itself as a matter of course or principle? Shrug. Sometimes the wrong choices of others can't be helped. > Fundamentally, if misinformation is more appealing and attractive than truths, how far can educational approaches go? Well, based on approximately the last 1000 years of history, considering that we have an orbiting science lab 400km above the Earth and outdated superstitions seem to be waning worldwide, I would venture a preliminary guess that in the long run, truth will win out. All of the other times we tried mass censorship, it ended very poorly, with millions upon millions of deaths. Trust in your fellow human beings. You can't have a society without trust. Most people are not malicious, nor are they exceedingly dumb. Let people read. If you're worried about people not knowing the things they need to know, or being mislead by wrong or bad information, I encourage you to write a book, or make a website. Hell, I'll even help you set it up, for free, if you need assistance doing so.
- mchusma 6y agoThanks for the follow up. I agree that people want to adjust what other people can read, but this is where Facebook can really sidestep this by making things user preferences. Because it sounds strange to campaign to force Facebook to "override a person's explicit preferences about what to show/hide".