4 ms·
Did we not have an air-to-air passive anti-radiation missile?
by exabrial 6y ago
Did we not have an air-to-air passive anti-radiation missile?
- justin66 6y agoThe air-to-ground ARM missiles were designed to remember where radar stations were with some precision so when they saw the missile coming and shut down, the missile could still hit them. The concept doesn't apply with an airplane that can shut down its radar and maneuver. If you design an ARM that also has a backup sensor (IR or radar) to follow the maneuvering aircraft, why not just make that the primary sensor? At which point you've got a standard air-to-air missile, except with some superfluous stuff on it?
- JshWright 6y agoIf you're targeting AWACS, even getting them to shut down is going to be pretty disruptive for your opponent.
- justin66 6y agoRight, but that was a hypothetical. They're not going to shut down, and you're not going to take your shot at them using a passive-sensor anti-radiation missile. You'll use a passive-sensor infrared or an actively guided radar missile. (And an AWACS plane isn't without other countermeasures.)
- aerostable_slug 6y agoFWIW, ASALM had a passive ARM guidance mode, switching to active radar homing in the endgame.
- ckozlowski 6y agoThe benefit to having "home on jam" in this case is that it's passive, (no warning to the target aircraft) and generally has a larger detection range than IR. AMRAAM has this capability now, which would allow for, in theory, long-range shots without the launching aircraft even having to illuminate. The AMRAAM's radar is short range, so you can use a combination of "home on jam" to guide to a range where the jamming is no longer effective, then go active and potentially make the kill. This is a simplistic example of course; EW being a very complicated subject. But overall, having multiple sensors that you can either correlate or fall back on is the trend in smart weapons right now, and we'll be seeing more of those sorts of combinations.
- LorenPechtel 6y agoHome on jam also has the benefit that it works when the enemy can jam your radar. You have an incoming enemy raid with heavy jammer support, you lob some missiles at it set for home on jam and their jammers are now calling them in.
- foxyv 6y agoAim-7MH Sparrows and AAMRAAMs have a home on Jamming feature which works because jamming is directional and continuous. Unfortunately with moving targets, home on radar is difficult. You only see the radar when it is pointed at you and a scanning radar you will only see blips. Also you can't get range and bearing so lead targeting is difficult. An anti-radiation missile may be able to home on a target that is using a Single Target Track mode. However it would have to ride the beam in and would still have trouble with terminal guidance if the target is cranking left or right. Also in that case, the enemy already knows where you are. The best passive tracking system I know of is the R-27ET which uses thermal tracking and is best against targets facing away (cold) to your plane. This is usually paired with an Electro-Optical or FLIR system on the plane for target acquisition.